The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 4 · April 1909
132printed page
scan 16 of 52
Facsimile · scan 16 of 52
Scan of p. 132
Text · transcribed from the scan

some claim to an honorable pedigree, refuse to pay any price whatever for rights we should never have been deprived of. We do not desire to purchase our emancipation, and not if Nicholas I. to-day should give equal rights to the Jews in Russia would be glad if the Russian Jews offered up a paean of thanks in the form of an abandonment of their pride of ancestry.

They have a habit of speaking of thelegalism of orthodoxy, and they advancepretention to lofty ideals, universal missions, and the like. But phrases nevercreated a true principle. Behind their pretensions, you will find upon analysis thattheir ideals are shoddy, their mission avain boast. If ever a people had a mission, it was the Jews; and only those Jewswho adhered to the national form of life,while the state per se had been dispersed,may be said to be carrying their missionto the Gentiles. A mission which has forits basis the principles of the unity of God,that formally sanctions the Ten Commandments, but repudiates the entire code ofJewish law which in truth created theJewish priest-people, is indeed but theghost of a mission. If the assimilationistswere honest and sincere, they would havecreated out of the Jewish state religion thereligion of a people without a state; theywould have taken the dietary laws, thesanitary regulations, the ritualistic precepts,claimed them all as their own, and thenhave allowed themselves to be scatteredover the four corners of the globe, clinging to this heritage, suffering for it, evendying for it. By doing that, they wouldhave justified their claims. But a religionwhich is so attenuated as is reform Judaism, which claims as little as possible fromthe Jewish past, which throws away oneafter the other every characteristic of Jewish life, cannot impose for long upon thecredulity of a thinking people; least of all,can they impose upon those Jews whoknow a little of Jewish history, who understand a little of the Jewish spirit, andwho know what motives inspire the trim-mers in the Jewish camp.

Because they are not sincere, because they are superficial, because they are merely adapting themselves to temporary conditions, we Zionists are not troubled overmuch by their performances. We understand the hopelessness of their contention. We know that it is difficult to perpetuate the Jewish religion in its full value in free countries, and at the same time retain the allegiance of Jews; much less probable is it that a reform Judaism, which has emasculated the virile strength of orthodoxy, will be able to retain the allegiance of any number of Jews for any length of time.

The apologizers and definers among the Jewish people are wasting their breath, for their definitions are never exact, and they are ineffective. It is evidence of serious sickness to keep on defining. Are the Jews a race, a religious community, are Jews usurers, are they good farmers, or are they capable of self-government, are they this and are they that; all this does not appeal to Zionists. We leave definitions to the sick in thought in Israel. We know that it will intensify their ailment, but we cannot help them. At least, we shall not succumb to the temptation to define. We do not define. We assert! We seek to make the most of what there is of value in Jewish life, and we seek to inspire in the Jewish people a desire to be what we think necessary for the well-being of the Jewish people and its future. We do not insist that the Jews are a nation, or a religious community; we are interested in knowing the facts, and with an assured foundation in fact, we hope to build up what we deem necessary for the Jewish future.

We find, as a matter of fact, that the Jews do feel themselves a nation in exile, with a hope for a return. We find, as a fact, that such a return is essential to the well-being of our people. Therefore, we appeal to the Jews: Make real your hopes, abandon dependence upon supernatural intervention, be up and doing for yourself. If you are not for yourselves, who will be?

It is a fact, that the Jews are capable