everything else within its comprehensive meaning. When Dr. Silverman glibly utters the phrase that the Jews are a religious community, he means to convey to the world his own divorce from Jewish life. He is anxious to demonstrate by word of mouth that he aims to be a foreigner among Jews; that he owes allegiance to no Jewish form of life; that he disowns the wealth of Jewish culture; that, in short, he intends to be the first man to jump into the American melting-pot, eager to proclaim its virtues, although the melting-pot may spew him forth when it finds that he is but a marrawless bone that will add nothing of value to the international stew.
"To speak of the Jews as a nation is to make use of a poetic fiction." If there were more poetry in the philosophy of the assimilationist Jew, we would see in their lives less materialism, less arrogance, less cheap, shoddy imitations of customs that do not fit. If there were more poetry in their lives, they would not behave like the new-rich, who, seeking to adopt the outward forms of social conventions, make themselves ridiculous by the awkward make-believe they would penetrate on a community as the genuine article. If there were more poetry in them, they would not glory in despising what their ancestors held dear, in repudiating all those traditions and customs that were born in the homes of their parents, not because they were seeking to make themselves a savoury smell in the nostrils of the stranger, but because it was pleasing in the sight of the God of Israel.
It is amazing how patient the rank andfile of Jews are to-day. They endure theranting of these men, without a complaint.They see poseurs, in the name of Judaismparade opinions that make a mock of itsprinciples, that treat with contempt itsgreatest exponents, that offer the judgment of weak, half-educated, shallowword-mongers, against the judgment of theprophets and the rabbis.
What right have these men to speak for Jews? There would be no objection,
if a Jew, finding it irksome to remain loyal to his people, should cast his lot with an alien people. No reasonable person would deny a man the right to leave the Jewish camp for whatever reason, whether it be because he wishes to be freed from the hindrances that limit the activities of a Jew, or because he wishes to have access to the best of alien society; or because he feels out of harmony with Jewish life.
But let him not speak in the name of the Jewish people. He may claim the right to his own interpretation of life, but let him not say that his own interpretation is that of the Jews. Let him be brave enough to proclaim his divorce from Judaism without deception.
The good name of the Jewish people ought to be protected against the slanderous statements of these men, for their abject cowardice in the face of Jewish difficulties brands every Jew with the crime of national servility, which we, and for that matter, a majority of the Jewish people, expressly repudiate. We do not apologize for our existence; we, Jewish people, do not seek to adjust Jewish principles to the exigencies of the hour; nor do we desire to pose in this world as the ultra-altruists, who, possessing in reality the greatest wealth, are prepared to fling it into the common pot of universalism, at a time when all other people are withholding their riches for their own development, at a time when such abnegation on our part would serve no useful purpose.
Their motives are not sincere. They do not speak from inner conviction. They reflect only the outward pressure. They are not the pioneers of a reformation, based on heretical opinions. What they believe, what they practice, is not their own belief, is not their own practice. They are the apes of the world, and we cannot let brazen imitators speak as if they had their birth in the Jewish past. The reform Jewish movement is a belated, useless, ignoble attempt to express thanks to those who liberated Jews from civil disabilities. They are paying a dear price for those civil rights, but we, as a people who have
