The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 2 · February 1909
44printed page
scan 4 of 54
Facsimile · scan 4 of 54
Scan of p. 44
Text · transcribed from the scan

one form of Jewish life, without creating another.

Before you can be free to create your own religion, with variations on the Jewish original, as it must be, you must free the Jewish religion of all its national elements, allowing those national elements to develop under normal conditions. Jewish life must be made to mean more than Judaism, in order that Judaism may not tremble at every danger which affects Jewish life.

Therefore the Jewish youth of America, who are not materialists, who are not atheists, who have faith though it does not conform, who hope to reconcile the phenomena of life with their religious hopes, are unable to go very far without an encounter with this peculiar situation. On the one hand the American Jew sees an anomolous form of arrested religion, and, on the other, a form of religion which has repudiated all those national elements, without which Jewish life becomes a ghost without a habitation, without which our heritage from our fathers is given away, denied, compromised, for the sale of comformity, assimilation, adjustment, etc. He has the choice of subduing his natural longing to have religion express his conception of truth, his relation to God and man, or of repudiating all those things in his own soul, which he has had from his forefathers, and which he does not wish to deny, give away, compromise or lose.

That is the religious dilemma of every progressive, thinking young Jew. The rabbis may not wish to see it, but we choose not to pass it over with pretence and hypocrisy. The American Jew must meet the issue. When life in all its complexity confronts him, he must get out of the dilemma, he must state his relation to the problem, he must adjust his life to the great past, which holds him, not in bondage, as so many think, but as a willing servant, in order to realize the best in his own individuality, and pass on to his children something of the heritage of which he is proud.

Nor is the religious cause the only one

that must prompt the American Jew to become a Zionist.

There is plain, ordinary, every-day gratitude to your parents, and through them to your ancestors. You are compelled to an interest in all the difficulties of the race, whose son you are. Not because they are over there and suffer, but because you yourself are so much less in value, as they are reduced in value. It is not altruism; it is ennobled self-respect. You bear the name Jew, and wherever a Jew is ill-treated, oppressed, contemned, despised, you are ill-treated, oppressed, despised. You feel their hurts, just as you feel the hurt of your own natural brother when he is hounded and maltreated. They strike you when they strike him. You cannot hold your head erect here, while over there Jews are being thrown to the ground and trampled upon. You may live far from the scene, but you cannot live your own life unless you have righted your brothers' wrong.

Your parents have implanted in you certain affections, certain hates, certain aspirations. They have breathed into you the traditions of Jewish life, of Jewish lore, of Jewish conceptions of nobility, of virtue, of dignity. Wherever those virtues, that dignity, that nobility is attacked, your own dignity, your own nobility, your own virtue vibrates in sympathy, and is seriously affected. The destruction of the Jewish people means the destruction of everything you hold to be noble in life, which you hope to transmit to your children. You cannot live a full life without having lifted your hand to redress the wrongs which the Jewish people endure, for your own personal interests are at stake. These interests may not be your own bread and butter, your home, your goods, but they are the higher interests of your individuality, which, if you are a Jewish nobleman, you will defend at the cost of your life, if need be.

Judaism is one of the manifestations of Jewish life. It is not the only manifestation when Zionism has entered into Jewish