enough to take offense at the insulting, un-Jewish, inquisitorial proposition made by Dr. Harris in the statement that if Jews cannot or do not believe in what he calls the Jewish faith, and do not practice Judaism, it were better that their children be brought up at least in the Christian faith.
This teacher of ethics and religion, who writes books on Jewish history where he condemns the efforts of Jews to maintain their own nationality against the Romans, forgets, however, that while there are many Jews who cannot utter the words of prayer, and who cannot regulate their lives according to the statutes of an arrested nationality, these same Jews wish to base their lives in Jewish thought, Jewish religion, Jewish tradition, but the conditions of life hamper the expression of their desires, and because they cannot get out of the fold without repudiating the Jewish brotherhood, which they hold dear, they prefer to reserve to their own homes the expression of the religion they believe in. They are not as glib as rabbis are, who so easily compromise with even the trivial incidents of life, who so easily formulate a pallid, empty monotheism, modelled on Christian forms. Jews who are Zionists are not so facile in forming their religion to suit the exigencies of a professional career.
We Zionists face Jewish life, see the abnormality of our position, admit that the Judaism we know cannot live in goluth unless we create a national center in Palestine, observe the demoralizing effect of the goluth spirit, the insidious inroads of assimilation, the dilution of Jewish ideals by alien forces, and we demand of the Jewish people that they assert their national or racial strength in order to give reality to our projects and to destroy these abnormalities and dangers. We are not so positive even that the Jewish people will respond. When Bar Cochba took up arms against a magnificent Roman army, he was not so certain that his brethren would respond to his call to arms; but his cause was just, it was necessary, and he
was bound to take up the fight. We are not victims of self-deception; we are not dreamers in that sense. We expect that there will be thousands of assimilating Jews, who, short-sighted and complacent, will take up arms against us, and denounce us, but we hope and we have the right to expect that they will have the decency not to invoke the Jewish religion or Jewish tradition against us.
A double dilemma confronts every American Jew, the Zionist as well, who is not orthodox. He sees before him an immobile Judiasm. The law decisions and the statutes of an arrested nationality, congealed in a religious form in order to conserve the Jewish people, are repugnant to democracy and especially to the American youth filled with impulses to have life reflect his own individuality. The hygienic regulations of the Jewish state, which have also become enslaved to religion, he would have scutinized by science and rejected if they do not stand the test.
The detailed methods of worship, the legislation that prescribes every movement on the Sabbath, cannot have any actual authority, wherever the Jew is free, and inner pressure does not demand it for ulterior reasons. Even the ideal of God, who once selected the Jews as his bearers of light and law cannot, unless there are reasons of national interest, be accepted without a protest against the arrogance of the claim, the absence of humility in it. Unless you admit the national authority, you are bound to deny the validity of Jewish law. Those who deny the existence of the Jewish nation, and live the Jewish traditional life, are like the blind fish in the mammoth cave of Kentucky who would insist on having eyes, where there is nothing to see.
The traditional law was effective while the world erected barriers against us, and we could not escape from the Jewish world. Here in America the barriers have been removed. But you cannot touch the traditional religion without destroying the form that had been created to preserve the Jewish future. You dare not remove
