The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 2 · February 1909
53printed page
scan 13 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN
53

nies .declared their independence and separation from the British crown, as belonging to every human being—God-given and inalienable—the right to pursue his own happiness. The English doctrine of perpetual and unchangeable allegiance to the government of one's birth, attending the subject wherever he goes, has never taken root in this country, although there are judicial dicta that a citizen cannot renounce his allegiance to the United States without the permission of the government, under regulations prescribed by law, and this would seem to be the opinion of Chancellor Kent, when he published his Commentaries. But a different doctrine prevails now. The naturalization laws have always proceeded upon the theory that any one can change his home and allegiance without the consent of his government. And we adopt as citizens those belonging to our race, who, coming from other lands, manifest attachment to our institutions, and desire to be incorporated with us. So profoundly convinced are we of the right of these immigrants from other countries, to change their residence and allegiance, that as soon as they are naturalized, they are deemed entitled, with the native-born, to all the protection which the government can extend to them wherever they may be, at home or abroad.

“And the same right which we accord to them to become citizens here is accorded to them as well as to the native-born, to transfer their allegiance from our government to that of other states.”

"So; therefore, if persons born or natural-

ized in the United States have removed from the country and renounced in any of the ordinary modes of renunciation, their citizenship, they thenceforth cease to be citizens of the United States."

Other opinions, confirmatory of the above could be cited, but sufficient has been given to establish a principle so obvious: that the right of naturalization implies necessarily the right of expatriation also. Indeed, this right is involved in the very idea of freedom itself, for without the power of choice in the matter of residence, we are not free men but slaves. Voluntary expatriation in itself involves no harm, no disloyalty, no shame, unless attended by shameful circumstances. In the words of Judge Jeremiah Black (9 Atty. Gen. Opinions, 356):

"The natural right of every free person, who owes no debts, and is not guilty of any crime, to leave the country of his birth, and in good faith and for an honest purpose, the privilege of throwing off his natural allegiance and substituting another allegiance in its place is incontestable."

We see then that an honest Zionist may unhesitatingly "believe and hope and labor for an ultimate restoration of Jewish political life, and the re-establishment of a Jewish nation," and that when such a hope is consummated he can without in any way reflecting upon his loyalty to America or Zion, choose freely between the two. He will owe political allegiance to the country in which he dwells, but it is inconceivable that he can fail in loyalty to either.