The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 2 · February 1909
52printed page
scan 12 of 54
52
THE MACCABAEAN

.to divert immigration from our shores, and to prevent a further congestion of the population of the ghettos of our large cities? Mr. Schiff is engaged in the same task. Congress has already enacted several bills restricting immigration to this country, and more drastic laws are advocated by powerful interests. We are doing no more than bowing to conditions; there is no disloyalty in yielding obedience to laws established and approved.

Our blood relationships with the Jews of Eastern Europe certainly involve obligations that we must satisfy. We were not accused of disloyalty to our country when we framed and forwarded through our government a protest against the Kisheneff massacre. We were not accused of disloyalty when we came to the relief of the survivors of this massacre with a generous donation of money. Our disloyalty must begin, then, when we seek to place them in a land of safety, under laws of their own making, and enforced by officers of their own choosing; when, in fact, we have established them in a country where they can enjoy such political rights as we possess in free America.

“If you are an honest Zionist,” argues Mr. Schiff, “you will owe allegiance to the government of Palestine, and this is not consistent with your allegiance to the United States.”

In this Mr. Schiff is mistaken. Aid and love and sympathy, a deep interest in its welfare and a desire to further it by all honorable means we shall indeed owe and gladly pay; but we can owe it no political allegiance, unless we become citizens of the Zionist State.

In spite of the fact that a majority of the Jews in the United States to-day are of foreign birth and have become citizens only by first denouncing allegiance to the countries of their nativity, the idea of a Jew becoming a citizen of another country strikes some of the anti-Zionists as acts of peculiar atrocity. Although they or their fathers in many instances evaded the laws of their own countries in order to gain citizenship in the United States,

they would arrogantly forbid others who desire, in accordance with law and in accordance with a principle maintained from the very birth of the republic, to expatriate themselves and become citizens of another state. Strange inconsistency!

state. Strange inconsistency? Strange misreading of the fundamental principles of free government! The bitterest complaints they make against the lands of their nativity is that they are there deprived of this right, and yet they are the first to deny this right to others. Fortunately our laws and their interpreters lend no support to these absurd contentions.

An act of Congress approved July 27, 1868, recognizes the right of expatriation in the following emphatic and unmistakable declaration

“Whereas the right of expatriation is a natural and inherent right of all people, indispensable to the enjoyments of the right of life, and the pursuit of happiness; and whereas in recognition of this principle this government has freely received emigrants from all nations, and invested them with the rights of citizenship; and whereas it is claimed that such citizens, with their descendants, are subjects of foreign states, owing allegiance to the governments thereof; and whereas it is necessary for the maintenance of public peace that this claim of foreign allegiance should be promptly and finally disavowed: Therefore any declaration, instruction, opinion, order or decision of any officer of the United States which denies, restricts, impairs, or questions the right of expatriation, is declared inconsistent with the fundamental principles of the Republic.”¹

Mr. Justice Field, in In Re. Look Tin Sing, 10 Sawy. (U. S.) 355, 21 Fed. Rep. 905, declared that:

"The United States recognize the right of every one to expatriate himself and choose another country. This right would seem to follow from the greater right proclaimed to the world in the memorable document in which the American colo-

¹i Federal Statutes, Annotated, page 788; U. S. Rev. Statutes, Sec. 1999.