The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · April 1908
140printed page
scan 16 of 38
140
THE MACCABAEAN

DR. PAUL NATHAN ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF PALESTINE

A reported interview with Dr. Paul Nathan by a representative of the N. Y. Times, under the double heading "The Zionist Plan Proved Impracticable" and "Dr. Nathan Explains that Palestine Can in no Wise be Regarded as a Place for Colonizing Jews" has been quoted extensively in a number of American papers. The gist of the interview was as follows:

“Every hope of repopulating Palestine with Jews from the lands in which they dwell at present must be abandoned. Palestine offers no inducement for Jewish emigration on a large scale. At present the agricultural and industrial conditions are such that outside assistance is necessary. Especially important at the present is the establishment of a good school system.

“The attitude of the Turkish government towards the Jews in Palestine and in other parts of the Ottoman Empire, is friendly. The Turks do not fear pernicious political activity on the part of the Jews. What the Jewish population of the Turkish Empire is in most pressing need of are a few large, central institutions of learning on the pattern of the American institutes (Constantinople and Beirut). The latter institutions are good, but the atmosphere is non-Jewish. The Jews of America and Europe can do nothing worthier for the elevation of the race in Ancient Judea, nor build a more lasting monument than through the establishment of a Jewish High School, where Christians and Mohamme- dans will be welcomed, but where the atmosphere will be Jewish.”

In view of the fact that the above interview did not sound genuine, in that it was self-contradictory, the Zionist organ, Die Welt, regarded it as important to verify the interview. To this end another interview was secured with Dr. Nathan, who kindly granted the following detailed statement:

"You ask me," he said, "whether it is really my opinion, that either in the near

or distant future a larger immigration of our coreligionists into the Orient, must of a necessity be discounted. Not in the least. I am only of the opinion that at this moment and in the very near future, such an immigration of the masses would by no means be a healthy one. Turkish Asia is now— I accent the now—not yet capable of receiving a large mass of immigrants; to make it capable of doing so, that is just the thing for which efforts must be made, and a beginning has already been made for the consummation of this aim. The railroads are developing the land, and it must be our task to equip our coreligionists who are already in the Orient, to be able to take part in this development. When the material prosperity of the Turkish-Asiatic possessions is enhanced through the introduction of modern technical methods, which they will no doubt secure, then the immigration problem will be altogether different from what it is at present. And if the Turkey of to-day still maintains the attitude, that immigration based on political motives must be resisted, it is to be hoped that she will withdraw these objections in the knowledge that organized immigrants promote the prosperity of a country, and every material strengthening of Turkey denotes at the same time a moral and political strengthening of the state. Distinction must be made, namely, between the present and the near future on the one side, and the distant future on the other.

"To-day, Turkey needs intellect and capital. How the capital is to be secured, that, I do not care to say, at this moment, but we can accomplish something for the intellectual advancement of the land by establishing for our coreligionists in the Orient, good and efficient schools, from the village school up to the modern technical school. When these conditions will be once and for all realized, then the Orient will be in a position to maintain larger masses of population than it can at this day. And with the help of modern technical education a people