The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 3 · March 1908
102printed page
scan 22 of 46
102
THE MACCABAEAN

The stipulations upon the part of the pupil are the following: He must keep his soul pure and train himself to be clean in spirit; during a lesson he must not be ashamed to ask about that which he does not know and he must willingly follow the teacher. He should barish from his mind all thoughts of wordly riches and remain content with little. He should commence by learning the first elements and principles of his science, then the deductions to be drawn from these and lastly the differences of opinions and doubts that have been expressed in regard to the subject. He should seek to encompass the whole of the subject and leave no corner in it unturned. He should never be idle day or night. His study should be an end in itself and not be carried on because of the honor or of the riches or of the great name he may thereby acquire. He should leave his own home and abide in a place where there is a house of science and a home of learning, and lastly, he should show his teacher even more honor than he is accustomed to show his parents. The complete curriculum which Ibn Aknin lays down he gives in the following order: reading and writing, Hebrew grammar, poetry (where he lays special stress upon memorizing and warns against poems of love as harmful for the young), the Talmud, theology, the philosophical disciplines and logic, arithmetic, geometry, optics, astronomy, music, mechanics, the natural sciences, medicine including physiology, biology, physics, botany; and finally metaphysics.

A curriculum like the one just sketched was of course in many cases a pium desideratum, but the spirit in which it was conceived and the elevated sentiments with which it inspires the spiritual side of the teacher's relations to his pupils, show to what height these men were able to rise. Their brethren living in central Europe and Italy were not so happily situated. They were surrounded by a hostile population, by a non-Semitic culture; and it was natural that their relation to this culture should be very different to that of their more favored brethren in Spain and in North Africa to the culture of the Mohammedans. These latter Jews had been privileged to find the great blending of their own culture with that

of their fellows. They had assimilated to themselves the true spirit of that culture; they had not attempted to be assimilated into it. The result was a decided gain to both sides, for it represented no unworthy surrender and no capitulation before an enemy strong merely in point of numbers. The best evidence of this is the fact so plainly evident that specific Jewish studies flourished there as they did no where else and produced that rare line of poets, Talmudists and philosophers which is the eternal glory of the Judaeo- Arabic period of our history.

The contrast to which I have referred is evident especially in the curriculum followed in the German and French schools of the same period. We miss entirely that freer outlook upon non-Jewish culture, that widening of the intellectual horizon. The subject matter of instruction is the old rota of Bible, Mishna and Talmud. We feel ourselves back again once more in the schools of Babylonia and Palestine, with the somewhat onesided insistence upon those disciplines—and those alone which were envolved upon an exclusively Jewish ground. They are more national in character; but it is a nationalism that is partial and confined and that views with a jaundiced eye everything that is not born upon its own soil that has not issued from out its own loins. To explain this contrast we have also to keep in mind the physical degradation in which the people lived, the narrow cramped-up lives which the circumstances of their condition forced upon them. A spirit of hostility to the outside world was begotten, together with a natural insistence upon that which was peculiarly their own. There was certainly no abatement of the love and the respect for learning. Instruction was obligatory, not by any formal law so much as by the general consensus of opinions which in a small and compact community is stronger than law. And yet, despite this, and insensibly, the influence of their surroundings excercised its effect upon them also, at least in the conduct and the arrangement of their schools. This can be seen in a document of the 13th century which has happily escaped destruction and which is a school ordinance or rescript emanating from some French com-