The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 1 · January 1908
2printed page
scan 6 of 46
2
THE MACCABAEAN

numerous obstacles, and demanding strenuous, wisely directed, ordered effort, without these sudden leaps backwards and forwards.

Due een I think, then, that the course of events will compel Zionism to come gradually to understand itself and its supporters:, to understand itself as a national movement of a spiritual character, whose aim is to satisfy the demand for a true and free national life; and to find its supporters in that nationalist section which is sufficiently conscious, in all its individual members, of this demand, and which in a certain sense may be called a “spiritual proletari- atn”

For, in spite of all the numerous latter-day sections of Jews, with their cryptic abbreviated names, it is still doubtful whether among all our “S.D.” and “S.S.” with their ceaseless talk about their “proletariate psychology,” there is really any considerable number of members who can properly be held to belong to the proletariate in the Socialist sense of the word. The mission of the proletariate is to hasten the Socialist solution by the concentration of wealth; and this mission can only be fulfilled by those who work in large industrial undertakings. The work of the master-work- -man and his assistants is not proletariate work, because, so far from hastening, it hinders that solution. Now the working-class Jew has practically no place in the large industrial undertakings; generally speaking, the so-called proletariate section of the Jews belongs to the class of master-workmen. But, on the other hand, there is among the Jews, and only among them, a proletariate in another sense—in the sense indicated by the combination of “national” and “spiritual.” The position and the needs of this proletariate, which are common to all its individual members, compel it to feel a deep-rooted and powerful desire for a change in the established order; but the change desired in this case is not a concentration of the means of production, but just the oppositee What is wanted is a new means of production, wherewith to create a product of a special character. Among all the cultured nations ours is the only one that has no special means of production of its own to create its spiritual and intellectual wealth, but is compelled to make use of the means pro-

vided by other nations—to wit, their languages, their literatures, their schools and universities, and so forth—and thus to enrich the owners of these means of production by its work.

But the proletariate that produces material wealth receives in payment at least a part of the wealth produced by its labor, and only the surplus is left to the owner of the means of production; whereas in our case almost all the result of our toil goes to swell the wealth of others. Our own national treasury is impoverished and empty; our own distinctive spirit dwindles and dwindles. And yet as a people we are rich in spiritual and intellectual powers, whose work is fruitful in every branch of life. This condition of things is distressing to all Jews whose kinship with their people is not one of blood merely, but whose national consciousness and general culture have developed to such a point that they can both understand and feel the deep tragedy of this national degradation. For the people so degraded produced thousands of years ago, for itself and with its own means of production, a store of spiritual wealth from which the world still draws sustenance; and it is impossible for them to imagine that all the endless sacrifices with which for two thousand years our people has paid for the preservation of its spirit and its own form of life are to have no result except to bring us at the present day to a condition of spiritual emptiness, the end of which will perhaps be a contemptible death. This constant feeling of distress necessarily impels these men to work for the freeing of our spirit and the products of our labor from alien dominion. Where there is a real want, be it physical or spiritual, there is a solid basis for a union of forces in joint work for the satisfaction of the common demand. And so it is the men who are really conscious of this want who form the only section specially fitted to support the Zionist movement, and to work for it unitedly, patiently, in an organized manner, until its goal is reached.

I am fully aware that not all who feel this need are as yet convinced that they must unite under the banner of Zionism. Many of them still believe in the possibility of freeing the Jewish spirit, and continuing its internal development, even without a national centre. But