THE MACCABAEAN
PALESTINE AS A CENTRE OF JEWISH CULTURE
Translated from the Hebrew of ACHAD HA'AM by LEON SIMON.
A well-known economist has correctly indicated one of the principal causes through which the doctrines of Marx made greater headway than similar doctrines before it. : Marx, he points out, made his socialistic movement the movement of a definite section of society—the "proletariate”’ — whose condition and whose wants inevitably produce in each of its individual members a deep-rooted and powerful desire for a change in the social order, and which is therefore really fitted to hght unitedly and patiently for the attainment of the ideal that promises the satisfaction of their common demands. His predecessors in the development of Socialism, on the other hand, stultified themselves by appealing generally to “the people," “the poor,” and similar undefined entities.?
A similar truth may be predicated of Zionism, though in a negative sense. One of the principal causes that have prevented Zionism hitherto from finding a firm and secure foundation is the fact that it has not so far succeeded in recognizing and defining its own "proletariate"—its natural body of supporters, which is really fitted to fight unwearyingly for the Zionist ideal, without being turned aside by every breath of wind. From its inception until the present day Zionism has appealed to "the people" generally. But "the people" is not its natural support, because the only want
1Part of an article published in the first number of Ha'omer, reprinted by THE MACCABAEAN from the "Jewish Literary Annual," 1907.
2Sombart, "Socialismus und sociale Bewegung" (1905), v. 61.
of which the great majority of the people is sufficiently conscious—the want which alone, therefore, can form the basis of common national work—is the need for freedom from material pressure. So soon as we leave this common ground, we find the people divided into sections and parties, whose conscious demands differ in each case, and whose relation to our national life, therefore, in each case takes on a different form. If, then, Zionism could really point the way to our material regeneration, it would doubtless unite under its banner the whole people, without distinction of sect or party, except, perhaps, that small minority which is already “emancipated” from all national ties, and stands on the threshold of. another way of escape from Galuth. But, as I have already said, the people does not see in Zionism the way to its material regeneration, and cannot see it there, because it is not there. The unsophisticated masses have always a “feeling for reality” that prevents them instinctively from believing in promises inconsistent with the reality before their eyes. It is only occasionally, in times of deep distress from which there is no escape, that the people will listen in large numbers to a promise of release that lets a ray of comfort into their hearts; but they turn away and disregard it as soon as they see hope of a remedy more in touch with reality. It is not strange, therefore, that Zionism, brief though its life has been, has already experienced many a sudden rise and many a sudden fall in the popular estimation, its fortune varying with circumstances. A people subject to such changes is not fitted to be the rank and file of a movement based on a long history, confronted by