The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 3 · September 1907
134printed page
scan 48 of 62
Facsimile · scan 48 of 62
Scan of p. 134
Text · transcribed from the scan

Bank, which was to be a political instrument, not a mere business undertaking. The same was the case with the National Fund, which was not intended to be applied to petty things.

Dr. C. Weitzmann pointed out the difficulties which had prevented the attainment of the Zionist goal, and therefore he set great value on the starting of preparatory work in Palestine. It was well known that for their ultimate success they needed money, and a large sum of money. What had they raised? A capital of only £300,000. The Turkish Government would require millions from them; how and when were the Zionists to obtain those millions. When they started practical work in Palestine, the bulk of the Jewish people, who had hitherto stood aloof from the movement, would understand them, and provide them with the money they required.

As soon as President Wolffsohn had taken the Chair in the morning, two interesting announcements were made. Profesor Warburg intimated that an English colleague had offered the last 500 trees for the Herzl Forest on condition that the number still required (nearly 5,000) was completed by the end of the present year. The other announcement was that, as the result of Herr Lewin’s address on Jewish National Education in Palestine, a number of the Mizrachi delegates had decided to establish a Secondary Hebrew School in Jerusalem, and had promised towards this object 3,000 marks annually for three years.

Professor Warburg, as President of the Standing Palestine Committee, replied to several of the speakers in yesterday’s discussion. He pointed out that scientific investigations were of great importance, as the Commission had already recognized; but to imagine, as some people did, that investigations should occupy the first place in the program, could only hawe entered into the minds of those who lived in the clouds. He had heard demands for concessions for the construction of harbors, railways, etc.; well, concessions were very pretty, theoretically, but they would cost immense sums and would be utterly useless if the organizations were not provided to carry them out. Incidentally, he regretted the seccessions of such men as Mandelstamm, Jasinowski and Zangwill from the movement, but he was con-

vinced that those who had remained would help to the utmost towards the attainment of their ultimate goal. Professor Warburg spoke of some of the ideas put forth by Dr. Alexander Marmorek, Herr Motzkin, Mr. Cowen and Mr. Greenberg as airships, and, referring to the demand for responsible government through a Committee to be established in Palestine, he explained the diflerence between Crown Colonies and self-governing Colonies in the British Empire, to point out that the work in Palestine must for a time be directed by the home Government of the movement until the settlements were fitted for self-onvernment

Dr. S. Lewin, referring to some comments by an English speaker (Mr. Cowen) on the dificulty experienced by Jews in obtaining the right of residence in Palestine, expressed the wish that he and those who shared his views would make a journey to Palestine. They would then find how firmly Jews were rooted to the soil. There was no country where the Jews enjoyed greater liberty than in the Turkish Empire; it was true that those in authority did not always interpret the laws in the correct sense, but the Jews could not demand more than was granted to Turks and Arabs. Herr Lewin commended the spirit which prevailed in the twenty-five colonies in Palestine; never had there been a conflict between tHfem, nor did the members make attacks on each other. This was a lesson which he recommend to the Jews in London, New York and Chicago. He pleaded for the means to develop culture and art among the Jews in Palestine, and asked whether it was not a disgrace that the only dwelling which was truly a work of art in the country, was a villa that had been built on the Mount of Olives by an English lady (Mrs. Laurence Oliphant). He reminded Congress that a new generation had sprung up in Palestine who demanded to work for their living; and it was the duty of their brethren to help them in this laudable purpose. He declared that when proper work had been done in Palestine the charter would follow.

Herr Syrkin moved:

The Eighth Zionist Congress, while recognizing practical work in Palestine as one of the most important methods for the realization of Zionism, declares with all precision and clear-