The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 3 · September 1907
133printed page
scan 47 of 62
Facsimile · scan 47 of 62
Scan of p. 133
Text · transcribed from the scan

would remain outside? What the Zionist organization must aim at was to obtain Palestine in order to strengthen their moral force everywhere. Who had stood up for the Jews who were massacred in Casablanca or persecuted in Roumania? They wanted a home not only for those who would go there, but also to have the moral force to defend those who would remain in the diaspora. That was why Zionists wanted Palestine, and to that end they required from Congress that it should perform national practical work. Having exhausted his ten minutes, Dr. Gaster obtained from Congress a further period of ten minutes, which he filled by an eloquent appeal for education (“cultur”—in the national sense).

The sitting, which was presided over during the latter portion by Heer Jakobus H. Kann, was then suspended.

AFTERNOON SESSION.

On resuming in the afternoon, Professor Warburg, who occupied the Chair pending the arrival of Herr Wolffsohn, announced that several motions had been submitted for the selection of general speakers, as time would not permit all the sixty delegates on the list to speak. The first motion was for twelve speakers, four each for more political, more practical and more "cultur" work. This motion was lost. The next proposal was for eight speakers, namely, three for more political, three for more practical and two for more "cultur" work. This motion having been carried, the delegate inscribed on the list retired to select the eight speakers. In the meantime some formal business affecting the National Fund and the Jewish Colonial Trust was transacted, and Dr. Ehrenpreis, Chief Rabbi of Bulgaria, read a paper on "Jewish National Education in the Diaspora."

The selection of general speakers having been completed, several points of order were raised before the speeches commenced.

Herr Kaplansky complained that although twenty members of the Poale Zion group, representing the proletariat, had entered their names on the list, only one had been selected as a speaker. He accordingly moved that the Poale Zion be empowered to choose an additional speaker.

Notwithstanding the previous decision of

the Congress, the President accepted the motion which was carried

Herr Schenkin was the first of the selected speakers. At the close of his speech, Miss Carmel Goldsmith intervened to correct a statement he had made respecting the work of the Ito

Herr Stamm urged that they should obtain in Palestine land, capital, banks, industrial and agricultural undertakings, and schools, and then the time would have arrived for political work. He was of opinion that the operations of the Jewish Colonial Trust should be conducted not in London, but in Palestine, preferably in Jaffa.

Dr. Alexander Marmorek said that, if his memory did not deceive him, that was the first time that he had intervened in the debate of any Congress. Probably he would not have abandoned his reserve even at that Congress were it not that they had arrived at an historic stage in their movement. He felt strongly that they must stand fast to the principles which had been inculcated in them by Dr. Herzl. He had striven to infuse his principles into the Zionists, but he (Dr. Marmorek) would ask whether they had learned enough or forgotten enough of that spirit. It was with dismay that he heard people speak of political Zionism as dead. Was it for this that Herzl had devoted the best years of his life? They boasted of being Herzl's pupils, but it appeared as though they were unwilling to follow his teachings. Petty Ghetto politics were now being advocated to the great injury of the movement. He and those who shared his views were not opposed to so-called practical work, but to the spirit which appeared to animate those who advocated it. He and his friends held fast to the political flag which was unfurled by Herzl, and would continue to sail under it. He repeated that some people taunted those who were loyal to that flag with being opposed to practical work. His profession had made him an expert in experiments, and he had leaned that all experiments were not successful, and that experiments might even be carried on for years without result. Herzl saw that for the purpose of the program they had need of the modern power—money—and for this reason he brought about the establishment of the