The Fall of the Reform Leaders
ZIONISM has compelled reform Judaism to take a position on the nationalist question unlike anything the first reformers ever dreamed of. Our early opponents smiled at us, nodded the head and waved the hand, and predicted that the First Congress would be the last. When Dr. Herzl died, the smile broadened, and it was declared that Zionism was bound to disappear.
Now, Zionism has actually become a menace to patriotism; it is a poison to the true Judaism expounded by ‚such believers as Dr. Joseph Krauskopf, Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, Dr. Kaufman Kohler and other disciples of progress and light. It is a movement to be fought; enough of this tolerance and sympathy; enough of coquetting with territorialism; enough of promising to be Zionists one day and repenting the next; all forms of Jewish nationalism are dangerous influences, which, if unmolested, will smother the great ideal known as the Jewish mission. Dr. Samuel Schulman stamps his feet and shakes complicated words out of a cavernous depth of thought; Dr. Emil G. Hirsch splatters the pages of the Reform Advocate with anti-Zionist abuse. Dr. Kohler persecutes three Zionist professors into resignation; and Reform Judaism steps out into the light with a new mission, the extermination of Zionists.
Well, we are content with having removed the mask from the face of the word-makers, and compelled them to prove their boasted principles. Reform Judaism has been a mission of phrases. It has prated of liberalism, universalism, progress, culture and enlightenment. But it had never been tested. It denied Talmudism, Kabbalism, denied this and that, but whenever it came to a declaration of positive beliefs, it shirked the duty.
Zionism has brought it face to face with an issue that will not down. How have the leaders in Reform Judaism met the test? Have they been tolerant, cultured, liberal in their dealings with Zionists; have they shown
any better principles than those exemplified by rabbis of orthodox schuls, whose mediavalism they affected to despise?
Their conduct toward Zionism has been what everybody has expected of them. In their everyday life, they have been snobbish, self-seeking, envious and shallow. They have been sensationalists, when sensation did not attack the vices of their own congregations, but conservatives when their own interests were at stake. Without going into details, the products of the Jewish “mission” have been sveonhancv and shallowness : of thoucht.
They have their reward.
They may fulminate against Zionism, but no one will be convinced. They have reduced themselves to mere shammasim .in their congrerations. and no one follows them.
They have made Judaism a convenient buffer against prejudice, but of the content of Judaism they have removed the kernel of life. When they led, they brought the Jews into the Valley of Death; now, when they have destroyed themselves, it matters not what they say or do. Confronted by a live issue, they have acted like worthy disciples of the Cherem method, which they have frequently denounced. In the light of vital questions, they have not proven to be worthy of consideration.
The present struggle between Zionism and reform in America means the undoing of the sophists who have made a mockery of the heritage of their fathers, who have trampled on every fine sentiment among the Jewish people, and who have worshipped Baal in a wilderness of platitudes and sophistries. We have brought out distinctly the points of cleavage in Jewish life. Those who are for a Jewish future are with us; those who are for the death of the Jewish people, are against us. They may talk of Jewish "science" and Jewish history, but to them all Jewish matters are dead things. With us, Jewish science, Jewish history, are vital, because out of them we hope to mould the Jewish future.
