The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
242printed page
scan 42 of 54
Facsimile · scan 42 of 54
Scan of p. 242
Text · transcribed from the scan

to increase the circulation of our party organ. A successful magazine will mean that the administration of the movement will have a dignified, ample source of income, which can be used to further other Zionist institutions.

REFORMATION AND INFORMATION.

A strong wave of conservatism seems to have swept over American Jewry of late. Interest in all matters Jewish has been kindled, and congregational as well as communal labors have won new fields. Customs long ago discarded and sentiments long unfelt have recently been recalled and revived. Individuals who had long ago deemed their last spark of Judaism extinguished have again joined our ranks.

To those who know only the Judaism of the last generation such a phenomenon in a progressive age may indeed appear inexplicable. In the light of history, however, it is a perfectly natural manifestation.

Strange as it may seem, the apparent retrogression is to be attributed not to any efforts on the part of conservative leaders, but rather to those of some of our reformers. A plurality of causes have, no doubt, been at work to bring about this reaction, yet chief among them is the indiscretion of the leaders in reform Judaism.

The early reformers were not only a product of conservative Judaism, but in all things save in the desire to secularize knowledge and to simplify and embellish religious observances, they themselves were conservative Jews.

But the people at large misunderstood the well-meaning efforts of their teachers and mistook "reform" for "destruction." As a result, Jewish learning, which had previously been the common possession of the masses, was fast being neglected by the communities, and the study of Judaism and its literature came to be considered as a fit occupation only for the leaders of congregations.

In the course of time leaders arose who, not having imbibed Jewish lore at its fountainhead, shared the mistake of the people at large and, vieing with each other in the introduction of reforms, they began to cut down mercilessly "the trees in the Lord's vineyard." It did not take long before religion and religious ideas

passed from a state of evolution into one of revolution. The most sacred things were divested of their sanctity and tradition and laws alike were proclaimed as a "dead letter." All Jewishness now being vested in the Temple and its services, even this institution in a very short time became unstable. But the rabbis, not realizing the true cause, endeavored by the most superficial and artificial means to keep it from falling.

A state of congregational restlessness and dissatisfaction ensued, but as long as the layman depended solely upon the rabbi for information and guidance the destroying process was allowed to go on.

Of very recent years, however, a change has come about. The late troubles in Russia and Roumania and the exertions of the thinking and feeling world that followed in behalf of the Jew has thrown a vast amount of informain his way. In addition to this, and even somewhat earlier, came the Zionist movement and made the Jew acquainted with his literature and his past, and through these, with himself. It showed him that the faith of his fathers deserved a better fate at his hands than the relegation to an empty edifice. It brought him to the consciousness that Judaism consists of infinitely more than the periodical visit (be it weekly or yearly) to the synagogue. It demonstrated to him that the seat of Jewishness is not within four enclosing walls, but rather in every Jewish heart. In a word, it wakened the national consciousness in him and convinced him of the fact that no man or men have the right to cripple the growth and to cut short the development of a living nation. .

Once informed, the layman could not help perceiving that he had for many years been misinformed and misguided by those who could and should have known better, and in consequence of his newly-gained information, he stepped in and called a halt to the destructive influences of his rabbi, and even now a strenuous effort is made by some of our leaders to check the revived spirit of conservatism, which in reality is true reform. Even now there are some who would prefer to remain blind to facts and others who do not even stop at throwing sand into other people's eyes. But it rests with the Jewish people at large to decide whether in years to come we shall have Reformation or Information.

MENDEL SILBER.