The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 2 · February 1907
75printed page
scan 41 of 52
Facsimile · scan 41 of 52
Scan of p. 75
Text · transcribed from the scan

to his argument in favor of Texas as a refuge for Jews, he felt it his duty to paint conditions here in the blackest colors. Consequently, he took an editorial from one of our foolish Jewish weeklies, with the caption, "Close the Northern Ports," and based an argument on the joke. If the Jewish press says, close the northern ports, of course all the Christian papers are saying it! But are all the Christian papers saying it? The idea was born in Pittsburg, and died there, and had its origin in the alarms that Jews themselves raise against the coming of Jews to New York.

Restriction of immigration goes hand in hand here not with prejudice, but with economic pressure. It is the echo of a protective tarıff, and represents the demand of union labor for equal protection with the capitalists. Whether Jews are closed up in New York or not does not affect the situation. As a matter of fact, the congestion in New York is solving its own evils. The migration from the East Side goes on every day. The East Side now extends from Coney Is’and to New Rochelle. If there is an immigration problem it is the Jews’ problem, and it relates itself not to an attempt to disarm prejudice by scattering, but how best to conserve the forces of Jewish life to ensure the best normal development of our people. That an adequate solution is possible in America, we are skeptical. On the one hand, the cry is, scatter them. But that will destroy Jewish individuality! On the other hand, the cry is, let them concentrate. But that will arouse prejudice!

To escape the dilemma, do both! Let them scatter, only, however, to reconcentrate and establish in more cities more Jewish centers. But this way of cutting the Gordian knot is most distasteful to the very people who are eager to scatter the Jews. They still have in mind that the scattering will actually destroy Jewish individuality, and that is what they want.

As a matter of fact, the Galveston movement, just as the Industrial Removal movement, supplied with funds practically from the same source, and for the same object—unless of course, "high politics" is playing its diplomatic game with another object—is doomed to do very little. The migrations of Jews are

subject to political, economic and psychological causes, and no organization will do very much to augment any movement unless the people have a leaning for it, and when they have a leaning for it, they will have no need for the Industrial Removal movement or the funds of the Rothschilds.

Zangwill, the Zionist, attacked the IKA for its dependence upon philanthropy. Zangwill, ITOist, co-operates with the IKA, or its representatives, when he finds it useful to depend upon philanthropy. And it is the novelist Zangwill, with his wonderfully fertile intellect and imagination, who builds the bridge the ITOist has crossed!

A TIMID AMERICAN LEADER.

Tue American Jewish Committee, whose birth occasioned so much argument in the Jewish world, is not destined to bear the palm alone unmolested, or, at least, its existence will not be as pleasant as was thought by the gentlemen who planned that national enterprise. There are occasional outbursts and protests that are disquieting.

At the Atlanta meeting of the Union of American Hebrew Organizations, Rabbi Moses Gries, of Cleveland, called upon the American Jewish Committee "to give up the ghost." His call was seconded by a number of inspired delegates, who seemed to want the Union to take up arms against the Committee with the object of claiming the leadership in American Jewry for itself.

But nothing definite came of this outburst except as it illuminated the character of the president of the B’nai B’rith., Mr. Adolph Kraus, who was foremost in opposition to the American Jewish Committee, who, in co-operation with Dr. Hirsch and others, sent in a protest against the first meeting, and who has since been an itching sore in the side of the Committee, nobly took upon himself to reply to Rabbi Gries, and inasmuch as he has been elected president of the Union, his position may be said to be endorsed by the convention, which represented the religious organizations of Reform Judaism.

Mr. Kraus defended the Committee very eloquently, but we have nothing to do with what he has to say; it is only the vacillating