The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 2 · February 1907
74printed page
scan 40 of 52
Facsimile · scan 40 of 52
Scan of p. 74
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

EDITORIAL PAGES

A Monthly Magazine under the supervision of the Federation of American Zionists

February, 1907

ANNOUNCEMENT.

THE Maccabaean Publishing Company announces that Mr. Louis Lipsky has taken the editorship of THE MACCABAEAN, with the active co-operation of Nathan T. Isaacs, of Cincinnati, J. de Haas and Horace M. Kallen, of Boston, and Mr. Abram Lipsky, of New York. It is hoped to increase the number of associate-editors from among capable writers in the movement. Mr. Louis Lipsky will be responsible for the editorial opinions of the magazine and its general editing.

THE Texan Zionists welcomed Dr. Shmaryahu Lewin as a representative of the Russian Duma. Was it an oversight not to welcome him as a representative Zionist, whose tour was conducted by Zionists, and who addressed Zionist meetings wherever he went? Dr. Lewin deserves a hearty welcome from every American Zionist, for he has quickened the spirit of the movement, roused intelligent enthusiasm and given us an impetus that will certainly inspire greater activity and more intelligent effort.

THE Jews in Russia occupy a very delicate position, and especially do the Zionists find it a difficult matter to decide what to do in the face of the revolution, which they are forced to enter. They are forced to enter the revolution, for, as Zionists, they have discarded the worn-out policy of approaching the government diplomatically. They have asserted their rights as men, and that in itself is an affront to bureaucracy. It is not surprising, therefore, that there are Zionists who favor united action for the attainment of Jewish rights, and that there are others who see

advantage in joining with the Cadets. But whatever Zionists or Jews in Russia may do, we may be sure that in every case open and direct opposition to despotism will be manifested.

DR. DAVID PHILIPSON, of Cincinnati, strikes the nail on the head when he says, in reply to his critics, that "The Zionist takes possession of the whole sum of Jewish endeavor and dubs it Zionism."

Zionism is a national movement, and every thing in Jewish life of a positive, constructive value, goes with it. Political Zionism is the method to be used in gaining a home for the Jewish nation. No part of Jewish life, be it reform or orthodox Judaism, can declare itself at one with the content of the life of the Jewish nation, and oppose the one movement that seeks to give a material basis to its life. Reform Judaism may be at variance with orthodox Judaism, but it cannot touch Zionism. Reform Judaism is only one of the phases of Jewish religious belief.

THE DREAMER OF THE GHETTO

Mr. ZANGWILL wishes to persuade himself that he is engaged in “real” politics and that he has the greatest contempt for the dreamer, but no one is convinced, for every time he speaks in public, it is apparent that he is still the author of the “Dreamers of the Ghetto,” and the greatest dreamer of them all..

His latest dream of “real” politics is the Galveston scheme. He has secured gifts from non-Zionists and non-nationalists, in favor of helping to divert immigration from New York to Texas. This, we are assured, is an independent enterprise, and has nothing to do with the Jewish Territorialist organization. But we beg to differ.

Mr. Zangwill has allowed himself to accept the territory thrust upon him by Jewish philanthropists, and has actually neglected to provide for his committee of investigation and exploration. That was one of the objections urged against Palestine by territorialists—we had not appointed a committee of exploration!

Nothing better illustrates Mr. Zangwill’s intellectual methods than the last speech he delivered in London, on Dec. 30. To give weight