The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 3 · March 1906
83printed page
scan 7 of 52

of the pure Talmudists, the defensive attempts of the innovators and the Chassidic Talmudists and Talmudic-Chas-sidim. If the original Chassidim had heard the statements of modern historians who credit them with the intention of making a protest against Rabbinism, they would doubtless not have been able to understand such an assertion; just as little as they were then able to understand why they were persecuted. They were, in fact, totally unaware that there could be anything in their doctrines and actions which was in anyway at variance with a single hallowed and recognized precept of Judaism. On the contrary, it was they who proclaimed their opponents as "Protestants," unlike the adherents of Luther, who themselves assumed that name.

Just as gradual evolution creates new positives tendencies, it is also likely to destroy old positive tendencies among individuals; inasmuch as it tries to weaken in them the hold of various needs and beliefs on which communal life is founded. These individuals now find, each in his own sphere, many superfluous things, the abolition of which would, in their opinion, lead to general improvement. These negative tendencies cohere in the same way, they arouse, strengthen and influence one another; and finally unite to form one complete theory, having as its center a fundamental and universal negation. Round this universal negation many of these individuals, the adherents of the partial negations, now congregate; and those who until now were detached, and were agreed, or even disagreed, in matters of detail, form henceforth one single force which declares war on the old positive theory, and the struggle is carried on exclusively in the name of negation and annihilation.

In a war of this kind there is neither complete victory for one faction, nor peace or reconciliation between the two; but an absolute severance for all time. Weary and

exhausted by the fatigue of battle, both sides retire from the field and abandon the strife. The adherents of the positive theory resume their mode of life according to the old principles, whilst the adherents of the negative theory separate from them, uniting to form a sect of their own which creates a code for itself in accordance with its principles. The rise of such a sect is a step backwards rather than a progressive move. It abolishes old beliefs and does not substitute any in their place, it simply endeavors to amplify what remains, so as to fill up the gap. In other words, it takes another old positive theory for a foundation, and links to it the "spiritual interests," hitherto associated with the destroyed tendency and now left without support. This expedient is sufficient so long as the struggle continues with the enemy: the negative by itself, which cleared the way for the new sect, becomes a source of energy and life which is helpful to the positive tendency—i. e. the "remnant" of the beliefs existing previous to the conflict. As soon as the outward struggle is ended and the negative theory betrays its true nature—its entire lack of substance—then its inner life must also come to a standstill. The "remnant" assumes again its proper dimensions and the uncovered space becomes stunted and impoverished.

The Karaites form a precise illustration of an exclusively negative movement such as this. Even before Anan, who is the accepted founder of Karaism, there existed "adherents of partial negations." These found no satisfaction in the hairsplitting discussions of the Babylonian School, nor in the ritual prescriptions which were daily threshed out. Still, as long as these "partial negations" did not unite to form a complete theory with a fundamental negation as its center, no new sect was established. As soon as Anan arose and condensed all these negations in one principle, viz., the destruction of belief in the "Oral Law" and the denial of the need for such