The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 3 · March 1906
82printed page
scan 6 of 52

cases both at the same time—though neither of them was known to exist before this moment. This tendency, according to a certain psychological law, discovers and awakens other tendencies of a similar kind, which now unite and give support to one another, till they all mingle to form one complete theory, which has as its central point the new positive need. Round about this central point are grouped a number of spiritual interests, such as beliefs, sensations, inclinations, needs, etc., which depend upon it, and are made to cohere by means of it.

A new theory of this kind, though its nature and origin are exclusively positive, necessarily involves some hidden negation. It must inevitably interfere at some point with a pre-existing theory, bearing upon a similar subject, and even if it does not injure the center of the old theory, it will certainly affect some tendency at its periphery. At any rate, the new theory prevents its adherents from devoting themselves to their old interests with the same zest as heretofore. The inevitable consequence is, that as soon as the innovators begin to put their theory into practice and try to realize the things they need by methods in which they believe, they will arouse through their action the opposition of the zealous adherents of the old theory, though the innovators had approached it with no evil intention. This opposition helps to spread the new theory, which will now attract from all sides those whose mental bias predisposes them to it. The greater the following becomes, the greater will be the antagonism of their opponents, and thus the opposition grows until it becomes a spiritual war of considerable magnitude.

The partisans of the new theory are at first indignant at being charged with the desire to destroy or dislocate the old—they vehemently declare that such an idea never has entered their minds—and they speak the truth. Their intention is indeed not to take way, but to add. They entirely lose sight of the negative which follows natural-

ly, because they are entirely absorbed in the positive addition. Even when the negative is discovered by their opponents, they try to conceal it not alone from others but also from themselves by artificial means which they do not recognize as artificial. On the other hand the adherents of the old theory, whose attention is fixed on the old, are for this reason better able to perceive or even to foresee the danger involved in the new movement, and they strive to prevent it from striking root. But, as a rule, the attempt is a failure. In spite of them the new theory wins for itself the position due to it in life. Both theories, new and old, little by little, drop those characteristics which are especially incompatible with one another. As far as possible they divide between themselves the interests of society—finally they unite and act in conjunction with each other. Thus the life of society has become enriched by a new growth, and this growth is positive.

The introduction of philosophy into Judaism in the Middle Ages was accomplished in such a way as this. At first a new positive theory in the minds of a few: the need for the understanding of the phenomena of nature and human life, and the belief in the possibility of their attainment by means of Arabic philosophy. Later—the spread of the theory, the opposition of the rabbis, who saw in it a menace to the old positive tendency—the dogmatic and ceremonial side of Judaism; the “defensive writings” of the innovators who denied the existence of the danger, till, finally, an understanding was arrived at between dogma and philosophy—the former developed into “pure religion,” the latter into “philosophy of religion.”

In the same way Chassidism arose and developed in modern times. At first—a new positive theory: the need for mental and emotional exaltation, and the belief in the possibility of its attainment by means of worship joyfully offered. Later—the spread of the theory, the resistance