The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 1 · January 1906
34printed page
scan 40 of 54
Facsimile · scan 40 of 54
Scan of p. 34
Text · transcribed from the scan

all public place. Judaism has again become a force with them. Many were brought back to the synagogue by Zionism. Many of them who had never seen a prayer-book in the houses of their parents began to study Hebrew and to show an interest in Jewish history and Jewish literature. Dr. Schechter said that as every great ideal movement, Zionism came into the world by various causes and has different aspects, but he certainly did not join it as a philanthropist. He left philanthropy to others, as he did not profess to be a man of affairs. What attracted him in Zionism was its anti-assimilation tendency and thoroughly Jewish aspect. He considered assimilation as insisted upon by certain of our leaders the greatest danger in Judaism. He read in this connection an extract from a recent article by a rabbi in which the latter exulted in the downfall of the Jewish nation, which died and was buried never to rise again. The rabbi further suggested that the Ninth Day of Ab ought to be a day of joy for every sensible Jew. Another rabbi declared that he is awaiting patiently when the last crumb of Hebrew will disappear from the temple. Dr. Schechter also heard and read often of a Zion craze. Now, he said, when such sentiments as just cited are expressed in the pulpit and the press, it is really time to go crazy. It was some New England writer who said that there are occasions in life on which a man ought to lose his mind. Those who retain it have no mind to lose. This is such an occasion.

Dr. Schechter said that he must not be misunderstood. He is as patriotic as anybody. He always insisted on a thorough knowledge of English literature on the part of the Jew, and could see nothing more desirable than that every Jew should become thoroughly American in every respect. Indeed, he thought we would possess today more Judaism and Jewishness in this country if we would have more of Americanism and less of Germanism. He further said that if this country should be in any trouble that would require the service of its citizens, he would say to his only boy: "My son, enlist, shoulder your gun and go to the defense of your country." But this does not mean that he should lose his individuality, his religion and bury his history. Zion and Jerusalem is still the spiritual center of all the great religions of the world, Christianity as well as Mohammedanism, and of the great majority of the Jews. A Christian lady of noble descent, whom Dr. Schechter met in the Holy Land, said to him: "Doctor, the English people consider Palestine as their second fatherland." Everybody who read Mr. Balfour's speech of last July must be aware that assimilation, if consistently carried out, means the abandoning of Judaism in the end. Mr. Balfour is

certainly not an anti-Semite. He is only a consistent thinker. There is now a great longing among us for unity and union, but unless this unity has some common ideal as a basis it can never be accomplished. Many contributions may create an organization, but for a union it should go deeper than your pocket. You require an ideal which should enlist also your soul, and this ideal can only be Zion and Jerusalem, sacred to all nations, civilized and uncivilized, promised unto us by the prophets, and prayed for during thousands of years, and still forming the object of hope and prayer to all the Jews, with the exception of a very small minority. Dr. Schechter referred to the manifesto which appeared last week in the Jewish Chronicle signed by prominent men in England. Dr. Schechter made it a rule never to contradict practical men in their own sphere, but the manifesto contained a sneer at a new ghetto or practically a ghetto State. With reference to this, Dr. Schechter said there are so many kinds of ghettoes in the world—a Christian ghetto, a Mohammedan ghetto, an ethical culture ghetto, and heaven knows, so many other ghettos! The only question was what sort of a ghetto one wanted to be in. Why should one object to live in a Jewish ghetto? The signatories of this manifesto apparently lived in a ghetto of their own, and Dr. Schechter felt sorry for them. Dr. Schechter strongly insisted on Zionism at home, and advised his audience to devote themselves to the study of Hebrew language, Jewish literature and Jewish history, to observe the Sabbath, the dietary laws, as well as to maintain other Jewish institutions. “Remembrance, thy name is hope.” And if you would not look to the past, you have nothing to hope for in the future. There is no nation without a language, without a literature, without a history, without institutions and without observances and ceremonies. Without these it is a mere gypsy camp. Dr. Schechter also said that he knows that there are so many practical difficulties in the way of the Zionists realizing their hopes. He pointed to the fact that no great movement and no great reform in history ever appeared practical in the beginning. The greater an idea, the more unpractical it appears at its birth. Dr. Schechter concluded his address with the following anecdote: In Italy, in 1848, after the revolution in Lombardy and Venice was suppressed by Rodez-sky, a certain Austrian man of letters said to his Italian colleague: “Well, you see your rising has been a complete failure.” “Why,” said the Italian, “you have not defeated us.” “How so?” answered the Austrian. “Have we not beaten your armies, dispersed your societies and imprisoned your leaders?” “Oh, no,” retorted the Italian, “this is only a fact, but we have the idea.”