The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 1 · January 1906
33printed page
scan 39 of 54
Facsimile · scan 39 of 54
Scan of p. 33
Text · transcribed from the scan

Prof. Schechter's Views on Zionism

PROFESSOR SCHECHTER delivered an address on Zionism at a Zionist meeting in New York, held at the Educational Alliance, under the auspices of the N. Y. Council. This was the first public statement of his position on the subject.

Dr. Schechter said, in part, that he came to pledge his allegiance to the cause of Zionism, to which he was enrolled as a member lately, and that it gave him much pleasure to have the opportunity of addressing this Zionistic audience. He thought that at his first appearance on a Zionistic platform it was only due to give an account of some of the phases through which he passed with regard to his attitude towards this great organization. Dr. Schechter watched the progress of Zionism for many years. He still remembers its beginning in such organizations as the Chovevi Zion, which, unfortunately, as he thinks, was allowed to fall into decay. He hesitated long before joining. His objections were of a theological nature. It need hardly be said that he was never led away by the cry of Zionism being un-Jewish. This cry, coming from those who are not especially known for their Judaism either in life or in thought, with whom the last book of a Protestant theologian becomes always their theological guide until another book by a more advanced member of the same church appears—the cry of un-Jewish coming from such quarters is more than ridiculous. Dr. Schechter was never led away by the talk of prophetic Judaism, of universalism and of a mission. Prophetic Judaism is not a discovery of recent date. Judaism always followed the prophets as they were interpreted by the synagogue and by the authorized teachers of the nation, but it did object to the construction put upon the prophets by the apostles of a hostile religion and by their modern followers, Jewish Christians. Nor is universalism an invention of the last century. It is as old as Judaism itself; both the Bible and our liturgy testify to it, but it never meant to the Jew racial suicide or religious suicide, or final absorption in

the ocean of humanity when it will please our divines to give the signal for our dissolution, and to sound the great horn for our freedom from tribalism and orientalism, and to give us a decent burial accompanied by a most solemn and unctuous funeral oration. No!

The life of man is numbered by days, And the days of Israel are innumerable.

Some of our divines, Dr. Schechter said,even now began to sound Jewish public opinion to see whether the time for giving thesignal has not yet arrived. As to a mission,he heartily believed that Judaism has a mission. But where are the missionaries? A missionary was certainly not a man who beginshis missionary activity by accepting the modeof life and thought of those whom he intendsto convert. We are good and honest citizens,but missionary activity is not one of ourstrong points. In his opinion missionariescould only develop on the classical ground ofPalestine, where the Jew, accessible to thesame influences under which the sweet singerof Israel came when he composed his "ZionHalo tishali," where every stone is a sacredmemory, where every piece of ground is asubject of holy inspiration, where every ruinspeaks sacred history—only there the Jewcould acquire this enthusiasm and religiouszeal which make the missionary expose hislife to all sorts of dangers in performing hisholy mission. What Dr. Schechter was afraidof was that the national aspect would obscurethe religious aspect; that is, it would try tosave the Jews at the expense of Judaism. ButDr. Schechter had occasion to alter his opinion in this respect some two years ago whenon a visit to Berlin, after an absence of nearlya quarter of a century. Matters then borequite a different aspect. A quarter of a century ago Judaism was practically unknownin university circles. It was a subject avoidedby all Jewish students. Whilst the Christianstudents were Germanisch Christl.ch, theJewish students were Germanisch; possiblysomething else, but never Jewish. But whenhe visited Berlin two years ago he found thatJewish students publicly acknowledged theirJudaism and discussed Jewish subjects andquestions of Jewish history and literature in