The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 4 · October 1905
212printed page
scan 46 of 54
Facsimile · scan 46 of 54
Scan of p. 212
Text · transcribed from the scan

out and that of British origin is therefor natural. They are, however, capable of a pro-Zionism, that is, if it re-originates with them as a result of local conditions. Something of this can be read between the lines of Mr. Zangwill's latest address, and Mr. Wolf —well, perhaps he is preparing for the landside.

Immigration.

THE alliance of Jewish organizations to help emigrants is fast coming to mean the suspension of immigration. Germany will not help the Jews en route to England, England will not help the Jews en route to the United States, that is, when help can be construed into assisted immigration.

We are sorry for the people; but we are not sorry for the failure of the "move on" policy. Things are happening exactly as predicted —the provision having been voiced by Herzl when he discussed the Roumanian situation. The theoretic right of people to come and go is fading from the popular mind; and the unnatural right to restrict gains fresh adherents daily. As the gates close, either softly or harshly, the heart cry wohin, wohin, grows louder and louder. Our own sloth, a wide spread purblindness, will force this eventually in every case—and then we will understand—and probably act. And yet how much more noble would it be if the Natural Idea responded merely to the ideal and not become the enforced reply to the most horrible necessity that ever confronted humanity.

Three Policies.

MR. ZANGWILL having joined forces with Mr. Lucien Wolf, Territorialism has, despite our prediction, passed its natal stage. Indeed, a shrewd English correspondent writes us in a private letter: "I believe Mr. Zangwill's movement will now gain support here, the feeling for action being now general." Whether the I. T. O., as the International Territorial Organization is to be known for short, will, however, go beyond Mr. Zangwill's ad-

dresses and Mr. Wolf's letters is a moot question. We take leave to doubt it. At the same time it is well to bear in mind that the Jews have now before them three sub-assimilative policies, all the sequence of Herzl's "Jewish State." There is political Zionism as we regular and organized Zionists understand our task; the Territorialist movement in process of formation, and the Russo-Jewish Bund. The distinctions between these ideas are as between a publicly recognized, legally assured home for the Jewish people in Palestine; an autonomous colony anywhere, but preferably at this juncture in the British possessions; and the recognition of an established Jewish nationality within the Russian pale of Jewish settlement. That there are three policies where there should be one is no doubt in a measure hurtful to the success of any one of them. For we do not believe that the Jews are strong enough to support three such efforts and still leave a balance of people either indifferent or devoted to the philanthropic efforts of the I. C. A., the Alliance Israelite and kindred organizations. It is still more clear to us that any one of these policies weakens itself when it diverts its attention from its main effort and expends its strength in cognate and subsidiary tasks. But with all these drawbacks, and we are in a formative period beyond which Herzl leaped at a single bound, it is with pardonable pride that we look upon these three institutions which in less than ten years have proved that the Jews, as Jews, can be moved by an ambition other than that of petty congregational success. Assimilation except for an occasional silly outburst has ceased to sway the minds of any one class. All those who cannot find their way into the ranks of one of the three parties unconsciously repeat the truism of the central propaganda and only fear to follow the logic of their ideas. Hence it is only a question of time when everyone who calls