THE MACCABAEAN
Editorial Pages. J. de Haas, Editor.
A Word in Season.
If we offer in these pages comradeship to Jewish Bundists and even Radicals whose idealism is far removed from Zionism, we claim the right to criticise such organizations from the bases of mutual friendship. No movement has offered the Bund and the Self-Defense movement more support than Zionism, but we must unconditionally withdraw from associations with the Bund if it fails to censure those who outrage the Jewish sense of decency by organizing balls or like entertainments on days sacred to the Jewish people.
What ever is done this year will have been done before these lines are published but the answer can not come to late, and failing attention on this side of the Atlantic we appeal to our contemporaries in Russia to strike a note of protest against the Anti-Jewish conduct of Jews anywhere who collect funds to protect Jewish interests.
We are quite prepared to be told that no organization can be held responsible for acts of isolated and irresponsible groups, and we admit the truth of the argument. But, nevertheless, such groups or individuals must be ostracised from anything that can be called Jewish life and Jewish effort.
Mr. Lucien Wolf.
MR. ZANGWILL is so keen to see the joke of the lamb lying down within the lion that it is remarkable that he is so ready to be swallowed by the wolf. We admit Mr. Lucien Wolf is a gain to Territorialism but it will be well to watch his gyrations and to watch whether or not he will drive the Zionism of Zangwill to the wall. Mr. Wolf has a curious record. He was once
like Mr. Zangwill, but more seriously, a champion of Orthodox Judaism, and a constructive Jewish communal politician. He did much to give breadth to Anglo-Jewish journalism and to him we owe that organized research which made the Jewish Historical Society of England, after which the American one is patterned, and helped to organize the Anglo-Jewish exhibition. He was one of the first of English writers to lay stress on Jewish consciousness. He turned, in print, Baron Hirsch and Dr. Herzl into a modern Moses and a Joshua. He sympathised with the Zionism of the late Col. Goldsmid and with Herzl, but discarded both at a critical juncture. Years ago he formed a literary friendship with Madame Novikoff, "O. K.," as she signed herself, a Russian salonist in London established there by the Russian Government. On this account he took the Russian Jews under his wing and sought in a measure to ward off Jewish attacks on Russia. He attacked Zangwill when the latter began his crusade against the I. C. A. and he attacked Zionism when Herzl began to negotiate with the British Government. He endeavored to give the movement a blow when he went to Russia and obtained an interview with Von Plehve. He has defended Zionism in the British Encyclopedia and attacked his own advocacy of the National Idea in his anti-Zangwillian letters. His support of Mr. Zangwill is now based on a hair splitting view,—it is in reality a flat contradiction of all he has said and done for a year past.
The explanation, if explanation there be of his conversion to Zionism without Zion, follows curiously the refusal of the community to side with him, and a general tendency in England to examine closely into the possibilities of the East African idea. The measure of his support must be measured by the measure in which he serves as indicator of Anglo-Jewish thought. The restrictions of aliens in England has hurt the Jews keenly; their anxiety for a way
