The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 1 · July 1905
22printed page
scan 26 of 72
Facsimile · scan 26 of 72
Scan of p. 22
Text · transcribed from the scan

* JEWISH LEDGER, New Orleans, La.—The editor and publisher of this paper is William A. Steeg. It follows the opinion of the American Israelite. It represents the German reform element of the city of New Orleans. It gives little attention to Zionist news, but it is not specially neglectful of the Zionist movement. It is largely made up of clippings, and has little of its own news.

* MENORAH MAGAZINE, New York.—A monthly publication, at one time the organ of the I. O. B. B., but at present representative of no organization. Its editor is not publicly known. It prints articles of all shades of opinion. It has no editorial columns.

† MODERN VIEW, St. Louis, Mo.—The editor of the Modern View is Abram Rosenthal, a layman, a fact which is obvious enough to the readers of that paper. Its views are expressed in the following editorial, written in reply to the letter of the committee:

“We are what is termed non-Zionists; that is, we are not for or against the movement as it stands, the journal has always given a very generous share of its columns to every utterance in favor or opposed to Zionism with the conscientious desire to get the benefit that comes from a free discussion in an impartial medium.

“Pressed for a more definite reply, we might say that we no not, at present, favor political Zionism; that we do not, at present, believe in the Uganda project; that we do believe in spiritual Zionism. We are open to change of opinion on either or all three of the points of inquiry, if we can be convincingly induced to change, either by better logic than is at present offered, or by more practical evidences of the promises of the movement, and greater unity of action and ideas than exists at present.

“The inducements suggested in the letter, namely, that there are many Zionists who would wish to subscribe for some Jewish weekly is a hint that it might be to our interest to declare ourselves pro-Zionist. We have a better opinion of our Zionist friends than that.

“We number quite a few Zionists among the readers of The Modern View and we feel sure that for the sake of their own cause and their intelligence they would prefer to read a jour-

nal which assures them a free and unrestricted opportunity to air their views, together with but one side of the movement and being only echoes of other voices. We have sufficient confidence in our Zionist friends to believe that the sincere assurance of the open hospitality of our columns to them will continue to keep for us their appreciated good will and co-operation."

* NEW ERA MAGAZINE, New York.—This is a monthly publication, but it contains editorial comment. Its editor at present is the Rev. George Alexander Kohut. He is not decidedly opposed to the movement, but the publishers of the magazine, who control its editorial opinion, are anti-Zionist on the usual “American patriotic” ground.

† JEWISH OUTLOOK, Denver, Col.—The editor of this paper is the Rev. William Friedman.. This is a new paper. It endorses the pulpit opinions of its editor, but it opens its columns very often to the Zionists of Denver. It represents the German Jewish element, which is strongly opposed to Zionism on various grounds. The Russian Jewish element is strongly Zionistic, and it may, in time, influence the editorial opinion of this paper by becoming active in various Jewish enterprises which will compel attention. In a recent editorial the editor of the Outlook predicted that before the lapse of many years the Zionist agitation will have spent its force and the movement will have shared the fate of similar well-meaning but misdirected efforts.

* REFORM ADVOCATE, Chicago, Ill.—The editor of this paper is Dr. Emil G. Hirsch. He is, so far as may be gathered from his writings, opposed to the nationalist movement. But his writings may be variously interpreted owing to the obscurity of the style in which they are written. He certainly believes in some Jewish mission, but whenever the Jewish mission is presented by his colleagues, he seems to be opposed to their version of it. He does not believe in Palestine as a colonizing center. He does not believe in the reestablishment of the Jewish state. He seems, however, to believe that there is some value in Zionist activity per se. But his chameleon-like views are beyond analysis. A frequent con-