The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 1 · July 1905
21printed page
scan 25 of 72
Facsimile · scan 25 of 72
Scan of p. 21
Text · transcribed from the scan

News. The editor of its English department is A. H. Fromenson, who is a Zionist. The Gazette, as well as the Daily News, is Zionistic, though they have, at times, opposed the Federation's methods.

* AMERICAN HeEBREw, New York. — The American Hebrew is edited by a Board, a number of whom, it is said, are Zionists. It does not believe that the Zionist movement can ever succeed, but it does believe that the consequences of the agitation of Zionism are beneficial to the Jewish people in that it helps to stem the tide of assimilation, stimulates the study of Hebrew, and strengthens religion. Therefore, at present, it offers no attack on Zionist principles, though it criticises the organization at times in a manner which is not always fair. It gives as much space to Zionism as can be expected.

* THE HEBREW, San Francisco, Cal.—The editor of this paper is Philo Jacoby. The Hebrew was established in 1868. It gives little attention to any kind of Jewish news. Its editorials are also, from time to time, clipped from other papers. Its attitude toward Zionism was expressed in its issue of May 19th, 1905. It endorses the opinion of the Modern View of St. Louis.

† AMERICAN ISRAELITE, Cincinnati.—The American Israelite was founded by the late Isaac M. Wise, who died before the recent development of Jewish nationalism. Dr. Wise was the leading spirit of the German Reform movement in America, and believed thoroughly in the Jewish mission. His son, Leo Wise, succeeded him as editor, and is assisted in his work by a number of rabbis. One of its editorial contributors is Max Heller, who is a Zionist, though, it has been observed, he writes nothing of Zionism in his contributions. The American Israelite does not treat Zionist news with fairness. Items of Zionist news are nearly always colored to suit the anti-Zionist sentiments of its management. It justifies its method of treating Zionist news by a declaration to the effect that it believes it right to fight Zionism in every way, if only it does not misrepresent facts, but it always intrudes its own depreciation of every item it gives to its readers.

The position of the Israelite on the main issue is as follows:

It "does not believe in the creation of a Jewish kingdom or commonwealth in Palestine with the idea of an ingathering of the Jews of the world, for that implies the abandonment of Israel's mission to the nations, which is, to teach them the Unity of God and the Brotherhood of Man. A Palestinian Jewish state necessarily implies a union of church and state, to which it is unalterably opposed. And even if one favored the idea of a state in Palestine. Palestine cannot be secured, for the Sultan dare no more cede Palestine from the Turkish Empire than the King of England could separate Ireland or Scotland from the British."

The Israelite is opposed to the Uganda scheme also, "even if the soil and climate are favorable for white settlement, because the distance from the railroad and ocean forms an insuperable objection, and no attempt at establishing a Jewish agricultural colony has met with success. The Israelite has not the remotest idea of what is meant by spiritual Zionism and seeks light and leading in this connection." What it wants to see is the Jews fully emancipated the world over, including Roumania and Russia, and given a fair field to win or lose as their individual merits deserve. It does not want to see them pent up in a small dead corner of the world. Until Jews enjoy full civil and political equality everywhere let such of them as find their conditions in their native land undesirable come to the United States or Canada or go to other of the British colonies and "there join the rest of us in working out their, our own and the world's salvation."

These are the views of the Israelite as expressed in a letter to the committee, copuled with an expression of esteem for the members of the committee.

* CHICAGO ISRAELITE, Chicago, Ill.—This is the Chicago edition of the American Israelite. In its news, it deals more fairly with the Zionist movement than its Cincinnati edition. The Rev. Tobias Schanfarber is the editor of the Chicago section. He is opposed to the movement, almost in the same manner as that of the editor of the Jewish American. He persists in the Jewish mission idea.