Why should one demand Russian patriotism from the Jews in Russia? Such a demand is unjust, inhuman, monstrous. But that the Jews whenever treated humanely and protected in their individual and national life can be patriots, sacrificing life and goods for their land hardly needs to be proved in this country.
One might perhaps raise the objection that the Jews are different from other politically dependent nationalities, since the latter live on their own territory, while the Jews have no claims on any territory in Europe.
The mere possibility of an objection like this excites the moral indignation of Dubnow the historian. He plunges into a lengthy historical investigation to show that the Jews have an historical and moral right on European territory equal to that of any other nation. The Jews as Roman eitizens colonized Western Europe long before the modern nations came into existence, and even in Russia we find the Jews at the threshold of Russian history. Poland was developed and eivilized mostly by Jewish endeavors, so much so that when in 1539 rumors were spread that the Jews of Lithuania intended to emigrate to Turkey, the Polish king, Sigismund I., ordered a striet investigation and was appeased only when he became convinced that the rumors were unfounded. And to make a special addition for America: On the ship which carried Columbus to the new world there were some Jews, and since 250 years the Jews in small and large numbers have contributed their best towards the upbuilding of this mighty republie. The fact that the territory claimed by the Jew is not confined to certain portions of Europe, as is, for instance, tbe case with the Poles and the Bohemians, but extends all over the continent, by no
means weakens the right of the Jew to consider himself the aboriginal inhabitant of Europe. The Jews in the Middle Ages were not persecuted on the ground of their being strangers, but as natives belonging to an heretical religion. But now that the nations have separated their political life from the religious, the Jewish people, though remaining a separate nation, can be and ought to be at the same time a fully recognized member in the circle of European nations.
In so strongly emphasizing the necessity of a separate and independent development of the Jewish nation, Dubnow might be charged with particularistic tendencies, with attempting to erect a new spiritual ghetto instead of the old ghetto of stone. Dubnow decidedly repudiates this charge. "Under no consideration do I advocate artificial isolation and separation. I maintain that the Jews and the Christians should approach each other, but on equal terms. The Jew in approaching the Christian shall not subordinate his own national individuality to the national individuality of the other, but both shall co-ordinate themselves before the highest demands of justice. If the Christian declines friendship on equal terms, then the Jew with self-respect will stop his efforts and live for himself. This you may call separation, but it is compulsory separation, aiming at the maintenance of individual freedom and national honor."
On the ground of all the preceding expositions, we may draw the following general conclusion:
"Jewish historico-spiritual Nationalism stands in no contradiction to the general political duties of the different portions of Jewry in different states. Just as every man can be a loving member of his family and at the same time a citizen of his country,so every group in Jewry, while