The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
251printed page
scan 27 of 56
THE MACCABAEAN
251

trous effects of this identification of state and church hardly need to be explained before an assembly of American citizens. After a long and passionate struggle, the civilized countries at last achieved the separation between church and state, most successfully and radically in this great republic. But the idea identifying state and nation and recognizing only one "ruling nationality," which is entitled to suppress all the other nationalities of the same state, is just as erroneous and certainly just as dangerous. In fact the countries with only one nationality are the exception. By far the most of them have a population consisting of different nationalities, be it the result of conquest as in Russia or Austria, or by peaceful convention, as in Switzerland or America. Where the state identifies itself with one nationality and tries to suppress or oppress the others, the result in political life is a series of disasters, compare Austria and Russia; where the state recognizes the equality and inner independence of all nationalities, the political order is safely and easily maintained, see America and Switzerland. Therefore we have clearly to distinguish between state and nationality, as has long been done with regard to state and religion. Where this distinction has not yet been made it is sure to be made in the course of natural development. The spheres of state and nationality are altogether different and do not clash with each other. "The state is a formal union, nationality an inner union. The members of the former are united by common interests, the members of the latter by common feelings and inclinations." Looked at from this standpoint, "Israel among the nations" becomes a natural and normal phenomenon. The Jews can at the same time be faithful citizens of their respective states and de-

voted members of their scattered nationality. The question is so often put whether the Jew can be a good citizen, a patriot,—we must not forget that Dubnow ıs here speaking as a European; in America I hope nobody will dare raise such a charge against the Jews. But he who asks in this way should be referred to all the other nations politically dependent, like the Irish in England, the Finns in Russia, the Bohemians in Aus- trıa, the Poles in their three different countries, and so on. A member of such a nation, provided his nationality be given equal rights and equal freedom of development with the other nations of the state, can be a faithful, a devoted eitizen of his country, a patriot. Wherever his national rights are trodden down, and his national existence threatened, his patriotism will be in accordance with the treatment he experiences. Let us take the Poles as an instance. The Poles are surely most ardent members of their nationality, which is divided among Russia, Austria, and Prussia. Nevertheless the Pole in Austria is a good eitizen of the Austrian Empire and takes an active part in its political life, while in Russia and, since recently, in Prussia his eitizenship is doubtful. The Jew, of course, whom the experience of past äges has taught to appreciate a home, is more modest in his demands, and is a good eitizen even where he is not properly treated. But he is by no means bound to it, from the standpoint of justice and morality. The obligations of the individual towards the state last only so long as the state lives up to its engagement: to defend the life and property of the individual. So it is with the nation. One would scarcely expect the Armenians to love the Turkish Empire whose only care for its Armenian sub- jeets manifests itself in butchering them.