The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
249printed page
scan 25 of 56
Facsimile · scan 25 of 56
Scan of p. 249
Text · transcribed from the scan

and noble. While we were fighting for the principles of liberty and equality, we ourselves prompted the violation of these principles by renouncing our own national freedom in favor of another caprice. Acknowledging the right of other nations stronger than ourselves to assimilate us or even to absorb us, we by this very admission justified the National Egoism of these nations, whereas to our own nation we denied the natural right even of National Individualism. And acting in this way we fancied ourselves the knights of universal brotherhood and cherished the hope that our national self-sacrifice which, as a matter of fact, was not an action of magnanimity but of pusillanimity will be rewarded by increased love and respect for us, until we were taught by experience that one acts respectfully only towards a personality, a character, but not towards a submissive creature which allows everybody to obliterate it."

Now that Nationalism has been stamped with the approval of Ethics, let us examine the peculiar nature of Jewish Nationalism. In order to understand Jewish Nationalism we have to establish first what national characteristics in general are and the way in which they gradually develop.

A nation, according to the definition of Dubnow, is an historico-cultural group possessing by virtue of its origin and the condition of its development, certain traits of character, a certain disposition of mental and moral faculties and a certain stock of historical traditions, distinguishing it from other equal groups,—in short, constituting a characteristic collective personality.

“The national characteristics (i.e., the traits of character, mental disposition and common traditions) develop in the way of an independent evolution, with

various phases—1, racial; 2, political; 3, historico-cultural; 4, spiritual, and in particular, religious.”

Racial characteristics are especially dominant in the primitive state of a nation, when it is a nation only in the physical significance of the word ("natus," birth, "natio," a species, an aggregate of kindred families or tribes).

In the next stage of development the political features come into prominence. A common territory and state which together constitute the idea of a fatherland closely knit the members of a nation to each other and preserve their national unity.

The highest degree of national development is designated by the rise of historico-cultural and spiritual forces. “Equal historical recollections, habits, inclinations, emotions, beliefs and ethical ideals as the result of national productiveness,—all this binds the members of the same nation with the strongest ties to each other. This is what we call the ‘National Spirit.’ This spiritual individuality it is which every nation, having gained self-consciousness, fights for when it is threatened by the intrusion of strange elements.”

In point of fact, these spiritual forces exercise enormous influence and form the principal basis of national unity as early as in the political stage of national development. “But there are cases, when a nation is compelled to renounce for a long time or for ever the protective cuticle of political independence. Such a moment is the touchstone of the strength of national feeling. If a given nation in consequence of a long historico-cultural development has become so much strengthened in its spirit that it feels able to preserve itself as an original national entity, despite the lack of political independence