The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
248printed page
scan 24 of 56
Facsimile · scan 24 of 56
Scan of p. 248
Text · transcribed from the scan

from Jews on either side of the Atlantic, and from the most high-minded and big-hearted among them. The fact in itself, that such an objection is raised, is most significant, and strikingly illustrates the crippled state of our inward life. If you were to ask the member of any nation, however small and insignificant, whether he is able to justify his attachment to his nation by abstract speculation, he would probably laugh at you or would even more probably fail to grasp your meaning altogether. If you were to put the same question to the Japanese, they would probably answer with cannons. But feelings that are a matter of course with other nations have first to be filtered philosophically and ethically before they can get access to the minds of the Jews. It is for this reason that Dubnow discusses this question fully and deliberately in various passages of his letters. His arguments on this point may be summed up as follows: A nation is a collective individual, i.e., though containing many single members it constitutes a sharply marked type, a national personality, with special characteristics, special ways, aims, and ideals that clearly distinguish it from any other collective individual. The freedom of the single individual has become an axiom in all the civilized countries, has become, as we ought to add, the cornerstone and the capstone of this great republic. In the same way the freedom of the individual nation, its right of independent existence and free development of its characteristics must become an established truth in national life. Those that are opposed to Nationalism on account of the repulsive forms which it sometimes assumes are just as shortsighted as the Rationalists of the eighteenth century who rejected all religion on the ground that it had often been abused. In former times when liberty was identi-

fied with equality, the justification of Nationalism could be doubted. But modern thought which proclaims the right and necessity of differentiation recognizes every attempt to equalize or obliterate individual and national characteristics as most disastrous to our civilization. We pay our tribute of recognition and admiration to the man who fully asserts and develops his own individuality, and object to him if he tries to achieve it by destroying other individualities. The same criterion we have to establish in national life. We have to distinguish between National Individualism which endeavors to preserve and defend its own nationality, and National Egoism which is aggressive and tries to suppress and annihilate all other nationalities. The latter is immoral; the former is not only justified, but is a moral requirement. Jewish Nationalism, in its essence spiritual, is naturally confined to a defensive course, is therefore in perfect accord with morality. The Jew who allows his own national personality to be suppressed by any other nation not only himself acts against all ethical principles, but he also induces others to act in the same way. "And only after having given sufficient thought to this obvious, simple truth, we realize how false a view of Nationalism has been held and partly is still being held by the majority of the advanced Jews in Western Europe and in Russia. How bitterly mistaken were we when in the name of 'liberal' principles we condemned so true a liberal principle as the right of every historical nation to preserve its individuality. We confounded two contradictory ideas with each other: National Individualism and National Egoism, forgetting that in the degree in which injury of the individual freedom of another is immoral, defense of one's own individuality is lofty