The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
208printed page
scan 32 of 54

conceived a plan calculated to remove all possibility of a future renewal of such agony.

Pinsker was a remarkable phenomenon. By education and environment far removed from influences tending toward nationalism, he yet laid down, in his "Auto-emancipation," the clearest and succinctest statement ever made, up to his time, of the indispensability of Jewish nationalism, if the Jew is to survive spiritually and physically. His call to the Jews of the Occident to take practical steps in pursuance of a large policy to meet the extreme situation in Russia having remained unheeded, he contented himself with the leadership, wise and enthusiastic, of the Chobebé Zion, though their aims fell far short of satisfying his nationalistic convictions. In Odessa, he, the prominent and respected physician, gathered about himself a circle of philanthropists, wealthy merchants, professional men, and litterateurs, whom he attached to the movement which, for lack of a better medium, he made the vehicle of his ideas. That these "intellectuals" were under the domination of his personality merely, and did not rise to the rare heights of that "national resolution" which he described as the absolute condition of the survival of the Jew as Jew, appears from the fact that after his death, which occurred in 1891, the circle dissolved, and of its members none, with the exception of Lilienblum, and perhaps one or two others, was heard of as an active sharer in the spiritual developments that followed and are taking place under our own eyes.

Pinsker himself, on the verge of old age, acquiesced, or was wise enough to appear to acquiesce, in the picayune methods and aims of the Chobebé Zion; was satisfied, or appeared to be satisfied, with the

comparatively small means collected and applied to colonization in Palestine; sympathized, or pretended to sympathize, with the delight of his followers in such achievements, as, for instance, that Baron Edmond de Rothschild was won as an adherent to the cause of the "Love of Zion." At the time when "The Way of Life" was written, all the forces of his movement were directed to the end of securing a charter from the Russian government, which, when obtained, would confine it to the definite, immediate, practical object therein declared.

This was the Jewish Odessa into which one day, about twenty years ago, there came, from a small Russian village, a young business man of means, education, and talent. The name of Asher Ginzberg was not known to the Jewish community of Odessa, but its possessor before long conquered an assured place in it. He entered the Pinsker circle, and in a short time became the trusted friend and lieutenant of the Chobebé Zion leader. In that circle, and among all in Odessa who thought and felt Jewishly, he quickly made himself known as the apostle of divine discontent. The paltry expedients of the Chobebé Zion offended his nationalistic aspirations, and when he had acquired, as he soon did acquire, a following from among the intelligent poor, the "Young Zionists," he infused into them his own dissatisfaction with the hesitating methods and half-hearted aims of the Chobebé Zion. He opened their eyes to the larger spiritual aspects of the Jewish problem as illustrated by 1882 in Russia, and their ears to the ominous rumblings foreboding that 1891 would again take the Jews of Russia and of the world at unawares—a much more saddening calamity than even the pillage, murder, and exile inflicted by besotted and barbarian haters.