Japan and that she had better remain unchristian. Did ever story better illustrate the value of being something, instead of sending out missionaries to talk about it to other people! Had the Christians only quietly formed Christian States at home, they would have converted Japan ata stroke, without an effort. Let the Jews, with their genius for righteousness, establish a Jewish State in which justice shall be better done than in any existing State, in which morality stands higher and crime lower, in which social problems are better solved, in which woman’s rights are equal to man’s, in which poverty and wealth are not so terribly divided, in which the simple life is the universal ideal; let them light this beacon fire of theirs upon Zion’s hill, or East Africa’s plateau, and they will do more for the Jewish mission than in twenty centuries of pulpit talking. And perhaps the world has no less need of such a new creation in States than we ourselves have.
But now comes the Jew who says, however desirable such a State may be, it is unattainable. To him the answer is, that it is he who helps to make it unattainable by staying outside. Zionism is not an athletic performance given by the Zionist leaders for the benefit of their brother Jews; it is a demand upon all Jews to give a hand in lifting the great stone that lies over the grave in which we are buried alive. One single hand that lies idle may make just the last ounce of difference between movement and dead weight. Whoever thinks a fatherland desirable—even if he thinks it unattainable—must enter our ranks. Nobody who stands outside us has the right to say that the desirable is the impossible—let him say so at our council tables, or on our platform, so that the
difficulties he sees may guide our plans, and the brain that sees them may endeavor to solve them. Zionism may fail, but we have the right to fail, we have not the right to refuse to try. I am not certain that the Jew who is overwhelmed by the difficulties should not well be classed with the sick Jew, for when he says that even if we founded the State, we could not run it, his talk has all the marks of the Jewish malady. He tells us that we should all be quarreling and fighting together, that we should all want to lead, that Jews in different countries have little in common, not even language, and he cites with horror and satisfaction the sordid and terrible episodes that disfigured our history when we really possessed Palestine. But all these things, if they proved our State impossible, would also prove the United States impossible. You are made up of different nationalities, you have had your war of North and South, your strife of Tammany and Citizens' Union, and so on and so on. As a matter of fact dissensions and quarrels and episodes have always formed part of the life of States, as they form part of the life of families, and if you wished to prove a Jewish State was impossible, you should set yourself to prove that it would be of a frozen lifelessness rather than to show it would possess those very qualities which all States have had and will have. Did you ever hear anybody object to family life because it has its troubles and bothers, and say that it is better to board with strangers than have a home and family of one's own? The problem of making a Jewish State out of the sweepings and gatherings of Jews from every side —each Jew informed as he is with the consciousness of the brotherhood of Israel—is assuredly not so dif—
