gered the Greeks and the Romans—are these mere moonshine? Has the whole human race been wrong, and are the anti-Zionists alone sane? No, anti-Zionism may disguise itself in philosophy, wrap itself in religion, but at bottom it is the Marrano habit in us that has become second nature; it is the yellow badge we wore for ages that is still stamped on our souls; it is the timidity and self-distrust born of centuries of persecution; it is the prisoner hugging his chains. All organs that are not used atrophy and decay; as mankind has lost the use of its toes from not climbing, so from not governing ourselves, we have lost the political instinct, the love of independence; we have grown blind like the fish that swim in the dark caves of Kentucky. Mark Twain tells of a prisoner who lived in a dungeon for twenty years. One day he had a bright idea—he opened the door and walked out. He could have done so any time those twenty years, but the idea had not occurred to him. I actually knew a man who lived twenty years on his back, under the impression that he was paralyzed. He wrote poems about his mattress-grave, as the Jew writes lamentations of his exile. One day there was an earthquake, and the patient leaped to his feet. Now he is married and has a family.
If a Jew tells you that a Jewish State is impossible, listen to him, for there are indeed grave difficulties. But if he says it is undesirable, then remember he is a poor sick patient, who should be treated in a sanatorium. He is suffering from hereditary Marranoism. If in addition he has cold shivers about “the Zionist peril,” the case is desperate. More pious critics admit a Jewish State is desirable, but say we must not
force the hand of Providence. What a splendid excuse for keeping our own hands in our pockets. In England we have a sect called the Peculiar People, which is much persecuted by the police, because it leaves its sick children to die without giving them medicine. Prayer is their only medicine. We have been too long a Peculiar People in this sense. The best form of prayer is work. If Palestine can never be ours till we are good enough for it, what better way of becoming good than by working for it? But I prefer the old Jew, who wept every fast of Ab for his country, instead of working for it, to the new Jew who says our mission is to be scattered. We were scattered by force after years of desperate fighting against the Romans, and if it was God’s will to scatter us, then it was blasphemous of our forefathers to resist the Romans at all, and to die in Jerusalem. M. de Plehve, when he was struck by the bombshell, might as well have claimed that it was his mission to be scattered. It is not even true that the Jews are scattered; the majority are congested in the Russian Pale and Galicia, and is there even an anti-Zionist who would deny that, if by a stroke of policy, the Pale could become an independent neutral State, the change would be an immense relief for our brethren? I admire the Jew who thinks we have a mission, but let him save himself before he babbles about saving the world. It is said that when a third of a century ago Japan was so marvelously transformed herself into a modern State, she sent out commissioners to Europe to discover whether she would not improve her moral condition by becoming Christian. Her commissioners, having explored the state of Christendom, returned and reported that there was more virtue in
