The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 5 · November 1904
218printed page
scan 6 of 56

ment. Color that lower region black and you need rainbow hues for the celestial sphere —no blackness below, then a vague light above suffices for our conception.

Other Western religionists are, in reality, no firmer or more positive in their actual beliefs of the Hereafter than the Jews, only they write and speak a good deal more about it. It guides the Moslem, and whatever the shape of it, the Japanese, but not the Christian. To the Crusader the thought was a very positive one. It entered into his calculations of life. In a volume on Science and Immortality (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.), issued, it is true, under the Ingersoll bequest, we find Dr. William Osler saying of the desire for immortality:

“Where among the educated and refined, much less among the masses, do we find any ardent desire for a future life? It is not a subject of drawing-room conversation, and the man whose habit is to buttonhole his acquaintances and inquire earnestly after their souls is shunned like the Ancient Mariner. Among the clergy it is not thought polite to refer to so delicate a topic except officially from the pulpit.”

And then he throws in this rebuke:

“If among the individuals we find but little indifference to this great question, what shall we say to the national and public sentiment? Immortality, and all that it means, is a dead issue in the great movements of the world. In the social and political forces, what account is taken by practical men of any eternal significance in life? Does it ever enter into the consideration of those control-

ling destinies of their fellow-creatures that this life is only a preparation for another?”

The answer of Christianity probably is that immortality is an individual, not a national issue; the answer of the Jew that he has national assurance of it, and the answer of the clergy —our Rabbis must answer for themselves, the topic would be more interesting than many of their topical sermons.

In an unpublished pamphlet, circulated by the author, Mr. Haim Guedalla (just deceased), What is Thought ?

in London, dealing with the Resurrection and kindred topics, we find the following on “Eternal Punishment After Death in the Next World”—we could be spared six of the words in the title— “It appears to me that there is no fixed belief entertained by ancient or modern Jews on this important subject, and, as a matter of necessity, where opinions cannot be anything more than surmises, much may be urged pro and con.” Nothing could be safer than this hesitant and redundant observation, but Mr. Guedalla is most emphatic on what we might term the necessities of Eternal Punishment. Writing of “Satan in Hell,” he says: “A belief in the devil is a perfect delusion. It detracts from the honor due to the Infinite Source of Power.” Without this machinery, eternal punishment must also be a delusion. But we think the attitude characteristic of the Jewish mind, and for the rest we must leave it to our learned pundits who, no doubt, know better what the Jew should believe, than what the Jewish brain really grips at and holds as realities. There is a great difference