The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 5 · November 1904
5scan
of 56

THE MACCABÆAN

Notes and Reflections

A reader "Perplexed" The Half-Way desires us to continue, House along lines other than we intended, the discussion on the Hereafter, incidentally raised in the last of these papers. We therein noted the observation of a friend that the Jew's belief in the world-to-come overshadowed all his other ideas. Of all things that we may be, we are not theologians, nor is this a theological publication; and, that aside, we are by no means so certain as our friend that a large mass of the Jews are not "emancipated" from the idea of Futurity.

That the Jews believe in an Hereafter, that indeed it is a cardinal dogma with all our sectaries, cannot be gainsaid; but on the other hand it is a moot point whether the attachment has been maintained at any such cost as the Jews have willingly paid for other ideas. To that there may come the response that all our martyrdom has been possible because all other ideas of belief and faith were subversive to this one central thought of the Kingdom of Heaven. "This world," said the Rabbis, "is the half-way house to the next." But our affection for the place of sojourn has been so noted as to have cause to be flung at us the charge of materialism.

And Judaism, with its large measure of deed as against fatih, of activity as against passivity, seems to bear this out.

The Jew dies serene in A Colorless the belief that he and the Heaven good of all nations inherit the World-to-come, but in his life he does not ponder the problem: Where shall I spend eternity, a question that, in letters of fire, seems to flame over before some Christian eyes. He is strong in the belief; why, then, should he perpend the question, and is not death itself a sufficient punishment to wipe out the stain of the normal sins of any ordinary life? Such, in all probability, is the way of the Jewish mind. The Jew does not color his heaven; it is largely an abstraction to him. There is Futurity —it is his by right. But we do not think that that explains the whole mental process.

Of course we shall be running full tilt against many preachers and sermonists, against parental suggestion and the Maase Buch, when we venture the suggestion that the Jew does not believe in Gehenna, the nether world, Hades, or Hell. We know of Satan and the accuser, but the Jew does not offset reward with the possibility of punish-