As to leaders, Dr. Gaster believes that we cannot have a successor to the throne, or pretenders to the crown. The election by the delegates does not create a Herzl, a leader by the choice of God. And he concludes with a suggestive, though confusing, statement. "The man, or the men, who would be elected to stand at the head of the movement cannot start work where Herzl stopped. The work will have to be done on a minor scale. They will have to start with a more modest programme, and try, in the first place, to heal the breach." The tendency of Dr. Gaster's criticism of the movement is not apparent to us; and will perhaps be less apparent to those not directly connected with the administration of the movement. Time will disclose the purpose, as time will heal the breach of which Dr. Gaster complains, without too zealous utterances in unfriendly journals.
Work of Societies
Our Zionist societies will be confronted when they receive this issue of the MACCABAEAN, with the problem of providing a program for their winter work. This is one of the most perplexing things in the movement, for everywhere the societies are confronted with incomplete plans and helpless appeals for something to do to sustain interest.
We believe that the movement is not well served by a large number of loosely organized societies, who have nothing in particular to do, and who can find no leaders capable of suggesting a program. Not alone do such societies hinder the movement, but they deceive the main organization as to the strength or capacity of our forces. We know that there are thousands of Zionists who are not affiliated with our organization, and we deplore the fact that they do not find it pos-
sible to join us; but we prefer Zionists who are not members of our organizations to those who, joining an organization in a lazy sort of way, do nothing to help it along, but remain in a helpless state of bewilderment from season to season.
There are many cities where constructive work has been begun; how this work has been done should be circulated among the societies. Leaders of societies are not only those who attend meetings and preside gracefully at business deliberations, but more especially those who can formulate plans of interest to the membership. Complaints come to us from many sources, and Zionists ask us, "What shall we do for the winter?" as if there can be any sufficiently strong outer force to create the right spirit in those who lack it.
The American Passport
THE United States Government has again formally proposed to Russia the opening of negotiations for the unrestricted recognition of American passports. The leading political parties of the country have adopted clauses in their platforms, asking for the unrestricted recognition of American passports in Russia, which may account in part for the reopening of negotiations. A report from St. Petersburg hints at the probability of success to these efforts of the United States Government. The report evidently being inspired, offers a tentative explanation of the Russian position.
It says that "while under ordinary circumstances, it is not probable that Russia would even yield to the extent of discussing a question affecting the internal policy of the Empire," and while compliance with the American wish would probably entail a change in Russian laws, the more liberal policy recently manifested
