that we are now face to face with "chaos," which is indeed an extreme view. It is true that one who withholds the truth now, conscious of the grave situation caused by the death of Herzl, fails to give expression to views calculated to tide over the difficulties.
But death does not hush all differences. Peace is desirable, but even the London Icwish Chronicle declares that from the tone of the article, Dr. Gaster will scarcely be surprised if he is not regarded as an emissary of peace; and there are probably many Zionists who would dispute the interpretation of events given by the Haham, in the words that the Zionists stand to-day bewildered and helpless at the grave of the leader. And these differences may be taken as evidence of strong life in the movement. At no time have they assumed such heights as to threaten whatever success has been attained.
Have the people been turned away from the road to Palestine through the forcing of the hand of the leader by irresponsible persons? Not at all. The East African question was an unavoidable incident in the growth of the movement. It was one of those incidents that could have been turned to great value had not the fear of a lack of faith in Palestine, because of its introduction, been so strong. We do not regret, as Dr. Gaster regrets, the bringing up of this question at a Zionist Congress. It is true, greater frankness in presenting the question to the Congress would have helped matters; but, whatever was done, was for the best interests of the cause; and whatever has resulted from its introduction will prove for the best.
What is to follow? asks Dr. Gaster. "Nothing that leads to a divided camp, to mutually destructive parties, to new ad-
ventures, to new experiments of a doubtful nature; nothing that shifts the movement from that common basis, on which the most divergent opinions in Judaism could join without sinking their individuality. But everything that would guide us to Palestine, that would carry out the dying wish of Herzl and bring him to the Holy Land by a direct, and not by the roundabout way of Uganda." In his eloquence, Dr. Gaster becomes too strenuous. He says, "Like chaff before the wind must the East African scheme be blown off the platform of Zionism." This, we submit, is not a very carefully considered statement, for deliberateness and caution must be exercised in disposing of the East African scheme.
In fact, this article by Dr. Gaster shows a perturbed mind dealing with a question that requires statesmanship. His entire argument shows an intense hatred of any thing but direct Palestinian effort. While we agree with him in this particular, it was not at all necessary, in advocating it, to minimize the value of East Africa. A movement, like a king, can make no mistakes; it cannot disown an accomplished fact. And he who comes out in the public press and unqualifiedly brands the work of a movement, a thing accomplished, as a disrupting influence harms more than he helps it.
Yet, in the main, aside from his deep-seated hatred of East Africa, Dr. Gaster advises most sane things. He advises that a Congress be called specially for the purpose of considering the situation, gathered not in haste, assembled not in a hurry, at the end of the year of mourning, after a period of peace and rest. Delegates, conscious of the great responsibilities resting upon their decision, will vote their yea and nay, and thereby seal their own future.
