sition of anxious to do, the historic consciousness itself was not a strong element in his nature. Under these circumstances, the anti-Jewish Palestinian attitude of the J. C. A. administration was fairly understood; and it was realized that it could never remain wholly anti-Zionistic, whilst it had in its councils men who, before the J. C. A. had risen to prominence, had devoted much of their time and thought to Palestinian colonization. In the year 1898 this party in the J. C. A. endeavored to take a step Zionwards. M. Neigo was in Palestine. He inspected the Hauran, part of the ancient wheat-belt of Palestine, and recommended the administration of the J. C. A. to purchase 300,000 dunam of these crown lands; but the consequences of such an investment were apparent to those who had no Palestinian sympathies. They opposed the business; and the late Mr. Alfred Louis Cohen, standing fast by what he considered to be the correct interpretation of the sphere of operations of the J. C. A. as laid down in the Deed of Trust, threatened that if the deal was not undone he would get legal advice and force his attitude in the courts of law. Whether he ever took such advice it is impossible to say now; but an obscure line in the reports of later years shows that the opposition succeeded, and that the business was never carried through. The J. C. A. withdrew from the transaction. Notwithstanding this, the J. C. A. could not resist the trend of Jewish policy. Here and there it began peddling out trifles to help Palestinian colonization, and at length took over the Rothschild colonies and administered them. Since that day the J. C. A. has been obliged to continue Palestinian colonization in order to help other colonies; and has latterly bought land in Palestine in order to meet the growing needs of the colonies already created.
Yet the question must remain whether this half-hearted policy is an honest one, and whether it in any way expresses the views of the creator of the institution. While they would go thus far when faced with more practical questions, when asked to aid Zionism as a whole, the administration have always fallen back upon their reading of their constitution; and if they have not hindered, which they probably have, they never have helped Zionism.
It is now our good fortune to be able to set at rest, once for all, the question of what Baron de Hirsch meant by founding the J. C. A. and what were his real views as to Palestine. Since August, 1891, at least ten gentlemen, many of them associated directly with the work of the J. C. A., could have spoken definitely on this question. Why they have remained silent is one of those questions that only they individually can answer. We give below in the original French, and with a translation made by the owner, a document written by Baron de Hirsch at Carlsbad, in August, 1891, which settles the question. For the history of this curious document and how it came into existence, we quote the following from Mr. Adam Rosenberg, an attorney of the city of New York, whose connection with the New York Chovevi Zion and the Shovey Zion societies is well known; and who has been good enough to place his copy of this interesting document at our disposal:
"When, about the middle of August, 1891, I arrived in Paris as representative of the New York Chovevi Zion and Shovey Zion Societies, and with a letter from the London Chovevi Zion (headed at that time by Col. Goldsmid and Mr. Elin d'Avigdor), offering Baron Edmund de Rothschild their co-operation in the Palestinian colonization work, I met there Mr. S. P. Rabinowitz, editor of the Kene-
