The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 3 · March 1904
118printed page
scan 18 of 48
Facsimile · scan 18 of 48
Scan of p. 118
Text · transcribed from the scan

The I. C. A. and Palestine.

BARON DE HIRSCH'S REAL VIEWS.

BARON MAURICE DE HIRSCH died in 1895; the Zionist movement as we now understand it, came into existence in 1896. Had the philanthropist lived one year more, or had the "Jewish State" been published one year earlier, a great conflict and much criticism might have been avoided; for, from the moment the Zionist movement took practical and positive shape, the minds of the vast majority of Jews ran, not unnaturally, to the various Hirsch Trusts as the financial co-workers of this scheme. The Baron had, in his lifetime, made provision for a scheme which should help in some measure to solve the intricacies of the Jewish problem. He founded the Jewish Colonization Association; he placed its government in the hands of delegates of the representative Jewish institutions; and at the death of the Baroness de Hirsch, the Jewish Colonization Association had at its disposal the largest capital ever available amongst the Jews for purposes of emigration, settlement and the like.

No other movement, in putting forth claims for the utilization of this money could at least put forward claims for using larger sums than the Zionists. The cogency of these claims, independent of the question of amount, has been continuously denied by the council of administration of the J. C. A. An element in this administration was and is, on its own account, anti-Palestinian as well as anti-Zionistic; and those who spoke in the name of the council as a whole, claimed that their trust did not permit them properly to deal or associate with Palestine.

This attitude was not maintained consistently. It was, however, urged in a

general way that Baron de Hirsch fret-in no way interested in Palestine, a ad, that his chief purpose in creating the J. C. fe A. was to move the Jews Westward and not Eastward. Hence it would not be justifiable, apart from technical questions, to use his money for Palestinian purposes. Technically, the deed of trust was worded in that obscure, indecisive language dear to the legal mind, and which permits the questioner of the clause to find an answer according to his sympathies.

Was Baron de Hirsch interested in Palestine? Heretofore the answer has been mainly, if not positively, in the negative; although some who are familiar with the more obscure phases of Jewish history during the last quarter of a century believe that Baron de Hirsch was at the back of Laurence Oliphant's enterprise in 1880. The reasons against an avowed interest in Palestine on the part of Baron de Hirsch were apparent. Having made money from the Turk in his railway ventures, it was known that he was not a persona grata at Constantinople. His friends included princes who were fighting for more complete disassociation from Turkish suzerainty; and purely from a Jewish point of view, it seemed, to use a phrase once current on the question, that he "desired to divide the world of philanthropic emigration with Baron Edmund de Rothschild; and as the latter had taken Palestine for his hobby, Baron de Hirsch devoted himself to the Argentine." That presumption was not without warrant; Hirsch loved undivided rule. He hindered his Argentine schemes by endeavoring to control them in the French method from Paris; and, however