The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 1 · January 1904
44printed page
scan 46 of 54
44
THE MACCABÆAN.
[January, 1904.

says about the Jews, in favor of the memorandum he has repared for the perusal of the Czar. His Imperial Majesty, the Czar of all the Russias, in that precious document is informed, "In the twentieth century civilization can no longer resort to the methods of the Middle Ages; Jews can no longer be slain in masses, sold into slavery or suddenly deprived of their property." It would be, perhaps, too much to hope that His Majesty will read this and ponder upon it; and that, moreover, M. Pobiedonosteff would also give a little, however little, consideration to this aphorism of Mr. White, especially as we are told concerning the interest of the Jews that he, "unlike Torquemada, has made a point of delegating to others the executive details of his policy. He has preferred to remain ignorant of what is being done in the name of Holy Russia. The result is that the Pobiedonosteff policy has been carried out with a precision generally associated with laboratory experiments on rabbits and dogs, pinioned but not drugged for the knife. It is a failure."

The attribute is as charming as the conclusion. But this does not prevent Mr. White from arguing calmly with the Russian Government; and the argument is that the Jewish question has become the burning question of the day; and being a question of international concern, Russia, the United States and England must convene a conference and settle the Jewish question. Like other such gatherings, Mr. White provides the conference itself with a cut and dried set of resolutions: Russia is to provide the land for the settlement of the Jews, and then the Hirsch millions, Jewish subscription and an appeal to Christendom are to

provide the means by which this land is to be settled.

This is not a Zionistic solution of the problem, but it is in line with the proposition made by the British Government in offering land in British East Africa. But Russia has made no offers or overtures. It does not seem very anxious to make them; nor yet do we know that the Jewish people, who are most intimately concerned, and who feel on the whole that they like as little being treated by the experimental knife of Mr. Arnold White, as by that weapon which the Holy Synod has employed, would be seized with enthusiasm, nor do they place extreme confidence in any proposition that might come from the Russian Government. This is the backbone of the problem; the Jewish people cannot very well, after their experiences, put so much faith in Russia as to allow it to reshape the destiny of Israel. Of course, Russia might find it convenient to shift the five millions of Jews, or a lesser number, from the western border of its empire, where it may any day have to face its natural opponents, to the eastern frontiers of its ever-extending territories. Five millions of Jews, or any such number, might comfortably settle in those great, wild spaces that lie between Siberia and Manchuria; with the additional satisfaction that a mass of Jews there could be roughly handled in the Russian fashion, without the world being very much the wiser, except upon very remarkable occasions.

No Zionist can object to that side of Mr. Arnold White's argument which recognizes that the Jewish problem is international, and that the persecution of Kishineff affected the position of the Jews in other countries, independent of