The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 1 · January 1904
43printed page
scan 45 of 54
January, 1904.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
12

project, and the most important of these is that the people should approach it with enthusiasm. The people do not do so. The Zionists in America, feeling it was a question for the sufferers to answer, rather concealed their antipathy to it, and this was the case with the majority of West European Zionists. So the answer is here, the answer that was anticipated in Basle, the answer that was offered to every doubting mind—if the Jewish people do not care to accept British East Africa then nothing will come of that scheme.

What changes are in store for us, and how the formal details will be arranged we know not, but we feel certain that the next congress will find this scheme among the numbered slain—dead because the Jewish people refused to breathe into it the spirit of life.

And what a wonderful lesson this of the truth of Zionism. Only a nation can carve out its destiny—neither a Hirsch with millions nor a British Government with a glittering offer of a home—none of these can do aught toward the permanent amelioration of the Jewish condition. Israel wants and Israel will have Zion—it will, because it wills it so. With giant strength our movement emerges from this struggle, because it has proved that there is something more immutable and enduring than a woman's love—the love of a people for their land. Zionism is above all scoffing. By what it has been offered and what it has refused it has shown that is most real, most true and most loyal. It was not for nothing that Dr. Herzl summed up at the last congress the whole ideal of Israel when he retook

the oath of our heritage, "If I forget thee, oh Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its cunning."

MR. ARNOLD WHITE

THE gentleman who is mainly responsible for and subtly incited. the formation of the British Brothers’ League, an organization whose agitation brought about the Alien Commission, Mr. Arnold White, in fact, who has played many rôles in connection with the Jewish question since his interest in it was aroused in 1884, has again raised his head in the pages of the North American Review; and it is to be presumed that those to whom his name is anethema are ready to smite him. Perhaps the heaving of a brick at him is not altogether unjustified, because he has proved himself to be, with all his pretended friendship, since the time his services as Baron de Hirsch’s investigator in Russia were discontinued, a considerable nuisance. The English type of anti-Semite is far more difficult to deal with than the Russian or the German or the French. His face is that of the unctuous righteous. He is so deeply interested in the welfare of the Jews that he must stir as many puddles as possible.

However, in this case we make no complaint against him. Whatever the underlying motive—and in this article Mr. White gives the whole of his personal record in connection with Jewish affairs—it must be admitted that by drawing attention to the Jewish question openly and frankly, he is doing the Jews some service, seeing that so many are unwilling to acknowledge the existence of the problem.

And we put aside much of what he