The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
357printed page
scan 26 of 63
December, 1903.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
357

that the proposal was not in accordance with the Basle programme, certainly they had not an atom of justification for bringing forward a proposition which runs diametrically contrary to it.

They had no right to minimize the character of the resolution, or resolutions, submitted and to force the delegates to vote by suggesting that it was only as a matter of politeness they were asked not to decline such a proposition on the part of the mighty English Government. They had neither the right nor the mandate on the part of the Zionists to enter into such negotiations and to place themselves and the delegates in such a painful position; nor were the delegates authorized by their constituents (who, like the delegates were kept in absolute ignorance), to vote upon a matter suddenly sprung upon them.

The Zionist Movement has suffered irreparable loss through this manœuvre; far from advancing, this proposal deals a serious blow at it, and it is no good blinking at it. What a puny Ghetto spirit furthermore is revealed, in the pride manifested that Zionism is now recognized as a factor of some importance, for a powerful Government like the English has condescended to treat pied a peid with Zionists. They forget altogether that the proposition is made to Zionists not as a furtherance of Zionism, that it is unmistakably anti-Zionistic, and surely it cannot be twisted into a recognition of Zionism as a political factor. The proposition of a settlement in East Africa is a negation of the fundamental principle of Zionism. What studied ignorance, besides, has been revealed by the fact of pretending not to know that the English Government treats with everybody, high or low, so long as it suits its political exigencies. I will touch later upon one of the possible reasons which may have induced the English Government to formulate that proposal, but I have still to consider the damage to Zionism which this aberration from its true aim is sure to cause to the movement. So long as we cling firmly to Palestine we may hope that our programme will sooner or later be taken into serious consideration by all the Powers that have a direct or indirect interest in the future of Palestine; and according to all appearances

our programme is taken into consideration in the European Chancellories.

Not that I expect they would do it out oflove for us; it would be gross self-deceptionto imagine that the Powers are so enamoredof us as to present us with Palestine, but because through a Jewish settlement in Palestine one of the most knotty and difficultproblems of the Oriental question would besolved in a peaceful manner. From the moment, however, that Jews who are consideredas representing Jewry, and still more so thosewhose sole aim and political activity has beendirected to acquire Palestine, so solemnlyand publicly declare that it makes no difference to them whether it be Palestine or anyother spot upon the earth, and such tremendous declaration is cheered by a majority—though a fictitious and misled majority—from that very minute Palestine—vanishesfrom our grasp and an offer is made to usto establish a Jewish "Liberia" in the Eastof Africa, just like the "Liberia" which hasbeen established in the West of Africa forthe negro slaves freed after the great American war. Surely we have not yet sunk solow as to be placed in the same category asthe freed negro slaves of North America! Ifany Jewish charitable institution, say the I.C. A. or the Alliance, had obtained such aconcession and had brought it forward, thedelegates of this Congress would have contemptuously refused to consider it, and howmany vials of wrath and righteous, unctuousindignation would have been poured out overtheir offending heads! I can almost hear theshriek of indignation which would haveshaken the Congress Hall, the echo reverberating through all Zionist assemblies. Howmuch more must we refuse to entertain itwhen such a preposterous proposition comesto us in the form and in the name of Zionism.

But unfortunately we are not discussing the matter now from a purely theoretical point of view. We have to deal with facts, and hard facts, which are staring us in the face, for the question has been put to us as a "practical" one, hitherto we have all been avowed "dreamers," and we must answer it, not only from the point of view of Zionism, but from the point of view in which it will affect the Jews in general. East Africa, or a small fraction, which, according to the