now no worse off than we were, say, 400 years ago, when the great scattering took place from Spain and Portugal. Have we lost entirely the belief in our eternity, and in the love and protection of our God of old, who has been the guide and the support of His chosen people? A colony in Africa would surely not put a stop to the dispersion. Instead of gathering the scattered, it would contribute to disperse them much more, and may contribute under the actual leadership to prevent them from really gathering in Zion. But whatever the fate of the venture, we are now face to face with stern facts, created by this unfortunate step which may have important bearings on the future of the Jews, and which may endanger the success of our true Zionistic work. Let us realize the change that has taken place during the last few months.
Only a short while ago the platform of the Zionists resounded with the cry, “There is a land without a people and a people without a land; let one be given to the other”; the people to the land, or the “next year in Jerusalem,” and similar pronouncements, which roused the enthusiasm of the people. Covert and overt attacks were levelled against the representatives of the Jewish charities because it was alleged, that through their abstention and hostility, the great hope of Zionism could not be realized. They scattered the people; they undertook to help the oppressed in the land of oppression, instead of helping them to emigrate; two statements, by the way, which neutralized one another. Now, suddenly, without warning, without preparation, all this is thrown overboard, the fiery denunciations and the rapturous clamors for Palestine are clean forgotten and more than a leaf is taken out of the book of these very charitable institutions. We are now coolly told, as if that were a matter of indifference, obstacles in the way of obtaining Palestine are now insurmountable.
A statement of this kind, coming from the mouths of the leaders, is of extreme gravity, for it seems to justify the opposition made by the societies and philanthropists which had hitherto declared that it was "Utopia," an impossible dream, not to be realized. Surely, if those who have taken upon themselves the political guidance of the movement have scarcely, after five years, come to the same
conclusion, they must certainly now have convinced themselves that it was an impossibility, for otherwise they would not have broken with the idea and would not have tried to escape into East Africa. Needless to say, I do not concur in any such pessimistic view, nor do I subscribe to that statement; for no one who can take the proper measure of the magnitude of this our undertaking could expect so quick a solution for so complicated a problem as the peaceful and legal acquisition of Palestine. I am now, more than ever, convinced that, in spite of the declaration solemnly made that it is impossible, it is nearer the realm of possibility than it was a few years ago. Regrettably as that statement is on their part and, to my mind, unjustifiable, still more to be deplored is the effect which the new trend of the movement, "New Zionism," is sure to have upon the Powers and upon the Christians who still believe in the inspiration of Holy Writ.
And I know from personal experience that it has been so. We are running the great danger of losing all the sympathy which we have hitherto won; the sympathy of the Kaiser, the benevolent neutrality of the Sultan and the promised assistance of the Russian Government, who only know of our aim to obtain Palestine and who, under certain circumstances, may be expected to help us so long as we cling steadfastly to it. The idea that the Jews may again be peopling Palestine has won us adherents and friends among the Christians who believe in the prophecies of the Bible, and it is not easy to see how we are to reach our goal without their practical assistance. A Christian friend of mine who holds a very high position here said to me the other day, that the Jews were just now undertaking a work pleasing to God, and therefore Satan is trying to destroy it; he has sent out now, as in ancient times, a lying spirit to lead us astray, and he has succeeded.
The policy of sitting on the fence should not exist in Zionism, and an alternative ought never to have been presented to a Zionist Congress, under any consideration. There is no substitute for Zion. If the leaders felt themselves justified in refusing without much ado a similar proposal made to them by the Sultan, without asking anyone, without submitting the proposal to the Congress, simply and solely because they believed