The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
239printed page
scan 40 of 80
October, 1903.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
239

our Zionist Congress was awarded the flattery of imitation, and representatives of the Jewish Colonization Association foregathered with members of the Alliance Israélite, the Anglo-Jewish Association, the Israelitische Allianz zu Wien, the Hilfsvereinen of German and Russian Jews, etc., etc., it was particularly ruled in advance that none of the resolutions adopted by the Conference should bind the bodies represented. Such a mutual mistrust we may deplore, as we deplore the jealousies between the Hilfsverein of German Jews and the German branches of the Alliance, but we are far from denying the philanthropic value of the operations of all these institutions, however they overlap in economic waste. But in so far as these institutions carry on operations that would be unnecessary if we had a country, operations that bid fair to go on forever, like the process of pouring water into a bucket with a hole in it, we have a right to ask them to reconsider their problem in a larger spirit, with a view to mending the bucket. If, however, they persist in playing with their problem and solving it not permanently, but from day to day, perpetually curing what they might have prevented, even so we must confess that the aid they bring, if less sure than ours, has—so far at any rate—been swifter. It is only when they set up a policy diametrically opposed to ours, which actually hampers or throws back our movement—as when they deport Jews from Palestine—that we have the right to fight them tooth and nail. And if, as we know happened at Berlin, the wiseacres in their assembled wisdom, resolve unanimously against the policy of emigration as the solution of the Judenfrage, and agree even to oppose it in all possible ways, then it is clearly our duty to oppose them in all possible ways. Evidently the only emigration that they approve of is emigration from Palestine. It throws a curious light on the bona fides of the Jewish Colonization Association, which exists only for emigration, that its representatives voted for such a resolution.

Anti-Emigration is indeed a policy which may be patriotic. For instance, an Anti-Emigration Society has just been founded in Ireland—to discourage the Irish from leaving their own soil. Our Anti-Emigration Societies are to discourage our people from getting a soil of their own. It is our old friend, the dogma that the Jewish Question can be solved in each individual country; a dogma which I shall presently bring under economic investigation.

ZIONISM AS A CHARITY ELIMINATOR.

So much for the institutions which are not superseded by our movement. But there are not a few institutions which the mere restoration of our people to a soil would at once destroy, while the mere organized effort to obtain a soil, and a center of political force, renders ridiculous, futile and petty, the operations of others.

Running my eye, for example, over the long list of Jewish charities in the Anglo-Jewish Year Book, I find that the very first in alphabetical order, the Anglo-Jewish Association, is destined to become antiquated, if, indeed, it be not already superseded. Founded (a) for the protection of persecuted Jews, (b) for the education of Jewish children in Eastern countries, its value as a political instrument is small. It can do little or nothing for the protection of persecuted Jews, as was obvious from the Kishineff episode, against which it dared not even protest. The effective protest, if, indeed, even that can be said to be effective, came from the American Jewry, but not even the American Jewry should take on itself such a national function. The protection of persecuted Jews can only be the work of Jewry as a whole. As for the education of Jewish children in Eastern countries, the work of the Anglo-Jewish Association only affects nine thousand pupils, most of the expense of whose education is really defrayed by the inhabitants themselves, and therefore its influence on the fortunes of our race is almost imperceptible.

Similarly superfluous when a Jewish State was formed would be the Russo-Jewish Committee, whose object is defined as "to promote the general welfare of Russian Jews who are the victims of religious persecution in their own country." This object is logically swallowed up in the larger aim of Zionism, and its funds might well be added to our exchequer.

Two other institutions belong equally to what may be termed the stage-coach period of Jewish politics and become obsolete in a railway and telegraph period. They are so strangely akin that if I were to draw up a list of their activities, an outsider would not be able to tell which was which. In fact, to discover from their respective operations which was the Alliance