The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
238printed page
scan 39 of 80
238
THE MACCABÆAN.
[October, 1903.]

Zionism and Charitable Institutions

Mr. I. Zangwill said:

Every movement demands its martyrs, and the thesis which I have undertaken is proof of my soldierly obedience. I trust my sacrifice will be of service in stimulating our freelances to remember that a national movement must move as one man, and not one man as a national movement. But I desire to accept sole responsibility for my conclusions, which seem to me the logical outcome of a unified view of the scattered phenomena.

MR. ISRAEL ZANGWILL

CHARITY ELIMINATION RATHER THAN CHARITY ORGANIZATION.

Zionism and charitable institutions. We know what Zionism is—what are charitable institutions? Charitable institutions are the visible signs of the breakdown of the social organism. In a perfect society they would not exist. Even now there are large strata of every society in which they do not exist. In fact, the frontier line of charity marks the lower limit of the dignified classes. The efforts of social reformers should therefore be directed less to the organization of charity than to its elimination.

When one casts one's eye over the vast evils of Jewry and remembers that Jews rank in the scale of organization below even the ant or the bee in having no hive or ant-hill, one is inclined to attribute all the misfortunes of the Jew to this absence of specific territory. Israel has been the Ulysses of history, and Homer gives us the opinion of Ulysses on the point:

Industrious Ulysses made reply : Naught is more wretched in a human race, Than country's want and shift from place to place,

But when one remembers that the poor we have always with us, even in countries like France or America, it is obvious that before calculating how much blame for these evils of Jewry we can lay on our landlessness, we must carefully deduct the general evils represented by the charitable institutions common to every country, which no country has ever succeeded in extirpating from its system.

ZIONISM AS A CHARITY ORGANIZER.

Personally, I am convinced that by scientific treatment these black spots on all civilizations could be minimized, if not altogether eliminated. And Zionism would not hold so much of our hopes if it did not include the hope that the Jewish State would find for the world the solution of these social problems, and that the race whose first lawgiver was so immeasurably ahead of all other legislators, both in science and in tenderness, would again produce a steersman to guide it as brilliantly through the new era by the light of the new science and the old love. Not to use every modern method for the creation of the sound mind in the sound body and for the well-being of the community as a whole rather than of any favored section, would be to be false to the principles of Moses our master.

I feel sure, also, that even among the charitable institutions which I am here broadly accepting as not traceable to the lack of a land, there are many whose functions would largely dwindle were the Jews again a territorial people, and this apart from the possible dwindling due to superior organization.

That many of these institutions overlap, and do one another's work, and get in one another's way, is another consideration, which, though true, I shall likewise leave on one side.

It is for them to unify themselves, so far as is practically possible, in the fashion recently set them by the Federation of American Jewish Charities, and even if they object to the Zionist movement, they may learn from it the lesson of unity and concentration. It is characteristic of Judæa to wait for a catastrophe like Kishineff before it occurs to its philanthropic bodies to unite their forces. But even at the recent International Kishineff Conference at Berlin, at which