The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 3 · September 1903
187printed page
scan 42 of 58
Facsimile · scan 42 of 58
Scan of p. 187
Text · transcribed from the scan

House of Bondage. There you have them, a long galaxy of great days, every one of them based, immutably, on the history of the Jewish people, on their experiences as a people. Difficult indeed have been the efforts of those who have sought to disentangle this national thread from the skein of Jewish life in order to get at the truly religious, the religious which can bear theologic definition, which bears reference to the God-power as the reason for its existence. These Jewish religionists have neglected to make a sharp division, for they have found it too evasive for their intellects. They have squinted at some festivals and stared others out of countenance, but throughout their endeavors they have never made one consistent attempt to revise their calendar on the basis of their assumed religious programme. Here we have a reform rabbi who believes that the nature significance of Succoth should be preserved. He hopes that the Chanuka lights will be rekindled in Jewish homes as a symbol of God's providence to the Jewish people. And yet, the Day of Atonement, which of all holidays contradicts his own view of sacrifice and atonement, so essentially a national holiday, fitted by the very expression of its ceremonials to be a national worship, is the chief one on his calendar, foremost in its emphasis on the dread of communion with God, and its allusions to anachronistic religious ceremonials.

All of which goes to show that so long as Jewish religion and Jewish nationalism will not be separated, and recognized as parallel phenomena, so long will this confusion of thinking and this chaotic theology last even with those who give our national movement its least support.

UNITED STATES IMMIGRATION

WITH a vast territory extending from ocean to ocean, with unexplored resources, and based on the Declaration of Independence, our country’s policy is indirectly referred to by the Christian Register, a liberal Christian weekly, “What shall be done with the Jews? In the east of Europe they are foreigners without foreign protection. Can we make homes for such a multitude of exiles as are looking in this direction?”

No one comes to our Christian friend and asks him to help build the homes of these exiles. They are building their own homes. They are building your great commercial em-poriums, your outreach of industry from plain to plain. It is not to these friends that any appeal is made. All that is asked is for freedom of access.

The United States is now coquetting with the immigration law. It finds it impossible to meet the two horns of a political dilemma. There are the Trusts, with their opposition to any restrictions on the incoming of labor, which they can use; and on the other hand, the clamor of the labor vote cannot be stifled. It is a choice between two evils, and out of evils come lawyers with their ingenious methods of evading the spirit of the law by crooking the letters. When they succeed in forming an immigration law which will satisfy the great capitalists and quiet the more noisy of the laboring men, we shall find our Spirit of Liberty standing at Ellis Island with a frown on its face and its back against the gate of entrance.

MR. BRAUN'S REPORT

THE United States has had an agent in the east of Europe for some time whose business it was to find out what the Jews were planning for immigration. It was surmised that Kishineff would rouse a great migration. This agent, Marcus Braun, a Jew, has presented his report, and declares that the immigrants are calculating on having the assistance of the Jewish Colonization Association and the B'nai B'rith. So far as the B'nai B'rith is concerned, an official denial was at once made. It was said in contradiction of the statement that at a recent conference of Jewish organizations, held in Berlin, it had been formally decided not to assist the immigration. Yet in the recent manoeuvres of the I. K. A. its plea was that its purpose was principally colonization, and if there is to be colonization, where will these colonists come from if not from persecuted centers of Jewish population? The same tactics of defense are being employed in the United States. Mr. Braun is called a renegade, and his statements, most of which are based on fact, are at once characterized as worthless, because he frankly