The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 3 · September 1903
186printed page
scan 41 of 58
Facsimile · scan 41 of 58
Scan of p. 186
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabæan

EDITORIAL PAGES LOUIS LIPSKY, ACTING EDITOR

THE KISHINEFF INCIDENT CLOSED

WITH diplomatic equanimity, our Secretary of State announces that the Kishineff petition incident is closed, and the gentlemen who are responsible for the petition have declared themselves as satisfied with the outcome, and say that all the correspondence will be placed in the archives of the United States for reference, should the historian want to know anything of it. We have nothing to say against the motives of those who engineered the protest. But we must deplore the means used to protest. The motive was the amelioration of conditions in Russia, if possible. That was good. We ourselves were against the loud expressions of denunciation of the Russian Government. But were the means adopted such as to attain the ends? Following the petition, we hear that the Russian Government charges the Jews with being involved in the revolutionary movement. Those Kishineff Jews who fled from the city and were settling elsewhere have been notified that they must return. Von Plehve is said to have remarked that Russia can get along with perhaps one and one half million less of Jews. The Bessarabetz continues. Russia knows full well of the agitation which has gone on in this country, and knows that it has been managed by the Jewish people, who have aroused whatever public opinion showed itself. And then, after all, what has the petition attempted to do? It has simply set forth, in the mildest sort of language, the facts which are internationally known, and which are admitted to be true even in Russia. For the transmission of this statement of fact, carefully worded so as to give no offence, all this agitation was undertaken, well night involving the United States in a diplomatic imbroglio with Russia, and jeopardizing American interests in Manchuria. The incident is closed; it should have been closed with more decision.

THE DUTY OF THE I. K. A.

IT is not our intention to say of the reports of the I. K. A., read at its last annual meeting, “Oh what a mess!” It is a great pity that men of such knowledge of affairs as is possessed by the trustees of the Fund should fritter away their time in scattered experiments in every corner of the globe. The wise people spend their time repairing the mistakes of the good people, said Zangwill recently. But goodness seldom will wait on wisdom; with the good people the feeling to do good is the best thing of the business, and ways and means are secondary. In Argentine the record is one of complete failure, and though the figures remain the same or are larger, the actual conditions are worse. The amount of money expended to keep the colonies on their feet, however, does not diminish from year to year. Evidently the assistance given does not produce strong independence, but its opposite. And what should one expect? These men go to Argentine or elsewhere with a feeling that the Fund owes them a living, and from the action of the trustees the illusion is confirmed. There is no constructive national policy behind their plans; no colonist feels that he is doing anything for his people by enduring privation. Let the I. K. A. once begin to act as the preserver of the Jewish people, and not of a few Jews from Vilna, from Bialystock, etc., and it will find that a new spirit will come into the work, a new ambition will thrill all those whom they aid and the fund will stand well on the road to becoming an invaluable source of Jewish regeneration.

NATIONAL AND THEOLOGICAL

THE Jewish religion is so constituted that it is impossible to disentangle it from all that mass of tradition which clustered around the Jewish people in their national capacity. The world has pressed into the Jewish religion, which it took on by reason of the necessities of defense, an hundred and one details which are purely nationalistic in their origin and in their significance. Strive as you will you cannot make of the Feast of Chanuka anything but a glorification of the patriotism of the Maccabees. Interpret and comment as you will, you cannot make Passover but a Song of Deliverance from the