philanthropy could not successfully start one hundred thousand families on a new career, our common sense would still teach us that the non-charitable method offered the most chances of success. We would have to create an artificial stimulus if we had not one to hand. But why should we?
Despite all our manifold divergences, the national idea is still the cohesive power which, in the first place, can unite all sects and schools in Jewry. We can divide upon all things except that we are Jews. We find, therefore, in the constant adumbration of this idea and the spread of its influence the real motive power which shall make the Zionist movement great enough, strong enough, and, if need be, sufficiently impetuous and enthusiastic to be able to solve the Jewish difficulty. It is only national will which can really solve national difficulties. Next this national idea, which has been the lever to unite the Jews to solve the problem, will enter upon a new phase, and become the power which shall hold compel him to share the national burdens of his new existence; it will influence him to be patient as an agriculturist; more than industrious as a mechanic. His responsibility will make him anxious to avoid placing obstacles in the way of his new-formed Government, and his new sense of respect for himself as a free citizen will make him more than ordinarily loyal.
Some people may think this Utopian. Let them simply look around them and see how Imperialism, an idea reborn for our generation, has affected the Germans and the English.
The German emerging from the burghership of some petty kingdom is to-day engaged in framing a welt-poitik, and having the force as well as the theory, has, in something over a quarter of a century, brought himself in touch with the four corners of the globe, magnifying his position and increasing his commerce beyond the dreams of the greatest of his forbears. The English have had the good fortune to be able to follow the old Jewish maxim, "Do, and then theorize." And now, if the task of empire-creating is not at an end, the period of theorizing has begun. The whole trend of English politics has changed, the divisions in political parties have been all re-created. Why? Because the English have suddenly caught a vision of their own position in the world, and the Englishman is not merely an inhabitant of free England, but a citizen of a mighty empire. Obedient to that vision, the tenor of his speech is changing, his sense of geography—if one may coin such a term—has grown, and developed, him fast to his new tasks. It will not only bring him to Jerusalem, but will and his idea of humanity has enlarged, and with it he has obtained a larger view of his political necessity. In America the same processes are at work. Now if Imperialism will do this for constituted nations, what will not a national idea do for a still disorganized mass of intelligent and enlightened beings. The answer is to be found in the various Zionist Congresses where the spirit of religious tolerance was manifested as it had never before been exhibited amongst Jews. That at least promises peace. Then the Congresses were sought to be turned into a parliament, and the whole present, as well as the future, legislated for, for that is what the culturfrage means. That at least promises willingness to be governed. Then, too, accounts have been rendered of the Jewish Colonial Trust.
