the United States. In the third place, the Jew has the gift of acclimatization, but does not really settle. The agricultural colonies in the Argentine do not attract, they are an artificial creation, they need artificial stimulus, there is no real sense of settlement amongst the colonists. After all, the Jew cannot feel at home amongst pampas grasses and Mexicans. There would no doubt be much difficulty in changing one hundred thousand Jews into agriculturists in Palestine, but however disillusionized by the difficulties of a farmer's life, the historic associations of Palestine would cast a spell upon the Jew. He can still turn from Argentina to Palestine in thought. However vague the latter represents the ideal to him, yet once there the whole current of his sentiments would have been changed before he could look upon Argentina as the ideal. Not that there would not be coming and going and restlessness, but the bulk would settle in reality with the home idea strong upon them. And they would, granted the realization of the Zionistic plan, even in a minor degree, have added to that the visible proofs in peace, equality, and rest, of the non-existence of their other troubles. They would no longer be a minority, and their growing numbers would not give rise to new local Jewish troubles.
Even if part of the foregoing paragraph seems open to contention, it must yet be admitted by the bitterest of opponents that the writer suggests no Elysium for Israel as the consequence of the success of the Zionist ideal. The direct object of the movement is to obtain a legally safeguarded and publicly secured home for the Jews in Palestine. This may or may not be a phrase equal to Jewish State. Indeed, the writer views it otherwise. No human movement proceeds on mathematical lines of progression. The beginning of all new lands is colonization and settlement; the end is an organism which is called a State, and may develop into an empire, to use the comparative designations of politicians. The Zionist end will not leap full-bodied into being; but without national will-force and national-end in view it would mean nothing at all—nothing worth ten minutes' serious consideration. With Chovevi Zionism—that is, the dumping-down progress, without security or plan—rampant, nothing but a new Jewish question would be created in Palestine, and the last of the "open doors" closed. Were the Jews to adopt a mere colonization policy, the emigration of tens of thousands would still have to be organized, funds would have to be raised by other than philanthropic methods, lands would have to be secured, legal guarantees obtained, and security of tenure thought of; the end would be Zionism, for the advocates of this policy admit that Palestine is the only possible land to which they can turn, if it only be desired to decrease the congestion and misery of Galicia. This would mean Zionism, but of a kind—Zionism foreshortened, a picture without a perspective, a policy without foresight.
Zionism, however, builds on better foundations. It is, strange as it may sound to those who simply catch the hurly-burly of debate and public assemblies, a movement of slow and natural progress. The good-will of the Powers is the last thing needed; the good-will, the united effort of the Jews is the first and prime necessity, and above all that sense of self-respect which is taught by patriotism even to the meanest of races. Were we not taught by experience that
