The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
36printed page
scan 31 of 86
Facsimile · scan 31 of 86
Scan of p. 36
Text · transcribed from the scan

Before American Jews had been acclimatized they had determined that, for appearance's sake, English should be the language of the synagogue and of the school. Whereupon throughout our country rabbis who could be tolerably eloquent in their native German, began floundering about in their complicated English. Before American Jews had settled as to their local religious schools, they began to long for national organizations to become their inspiration. Before the women had fully entered into the congregational life which reform Judaism opened up for them, before they had established their local organizations, they were wandering about like unmoored spirits, seeking consolation in biennial conventions with units that represented all shades of ghostly existence. Before American Jews had fully awakened to the need of education in so-called "secular" matters, an intrepid, sincere, and hard-working rabbi had forestalled everybody with a Summer School that had one virtue: It was situated where the cool salt breeze of the ocean calmed the ruffled spirits of the weary. And actuated by the same impulses, by the premature energies of officials who wanted to do something unusual, the most incongruous and empty kind of organizations have been hoisted upon American Jewry. Pretension has been met with more exaggerated pretension, until we may say in truth that our educational institutions are watered to the extent of fifty per cent. of their real value. We have become victims of the inflation, and though the silver question has died away, we are still under its influence. We are under the spell of numbers and noise. We are sacrifices on the altar of immediate notoriety.

What are the American religious schools? They are not places where Jewish life is imparted. A few maxims, a few rules of conduct, Biblical stories, are given over to the children in the most inconsequential way, as if even all those ancient records were sufficient to inspire present Jewish feeling without Jewish instructors. The post-Biblical history of the Jews, the record of suffering, which children should be taught to resent, is made a eulogy of the Jewish people, as if the fact of the continued existence of the Jews and so-called Jewish martyrdom can be reconciled. The whole train of Jewish life has been wofully mistaken in the mad attempt to make Jewish history stand as the record of an exceptionally good people. This is due to the Jewish mission idea, which rests on the superiority of the Jewish people, and if the Jewish people are superior, then what is left for life but a brass band accompaniment to the tune of our greatness? Having been torn away, more or less, from the main life of Jewish tradition, having come to their confused view by way of compromise, their children are growing up with artless, colorless notions of religion which are destructive of all vigorous interest and devotion.

It is the boast of the American brand of the Jewish religion that it has liberated its women. The products of that emancipation are the Sisterhoods, the Council of Jewish Women, and female "tasters of sermons." It is true that reform Judaism has liberated the Jewish woman? Who does not know that even in our day in certain quarters the Jewish girl receives her home instruction in the Jewish way of living, in domestic science, and in all those things which it is the privilege and duty of woman to make her own? Who does not know that the Jewish women of the old country, never coming under the influence of club or circle, know more of the duties of motherhood and wifehood, of religious traditions, of dietetics and hygiene, than many a leader of a Jewish congregation? And in charity, who but the women, the sterling Jewish mothers of old, were its dispensers, the sympathizers and the investigators? The Jewish religion certainly does not sympathize with the principles of the modern attempt to violate the innate qualities of womanhood and to assert the equality in strength and powers and duties of men and women. The educational organizations of American Jewish women stand for mere "ideas," unchecked by principle or practicality. And because of this, the circles of the Council of Jewish Women are pale, ineffectual things that never come up out of the negative stage of existence. Lately, in this organization, the educational feature has faded away before the great philanthropic interests of the day, and in a listless sort of way it is being absorbed into that ever-growing number of charitable organizations which are ever inadequate and year by year are becoming more and more vital to our existence. The career of the Council has been marked by futile attempts to reconcile Browning with Jewish history, David