The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
35printed page
scan 30 of 86
Facsimile · scan 30 of 86
Scan of p. 35
Text · transcribed from the scan

dox Jews insist that Judaism here is a failure. It is one of our American paradoxes that Judaism is always a failure with good Jews and a great success with those who cling least to it.

Now, contrasted with the Chedorim, on the other hand, we have a great proportion of our Jewish educational institutions swerving away from the idea that Jewish teaching must mean instruction in the way of life. Those who speak for American Jewry are those who have been expelled into modern life, who have come in contact with that life with a feeling of gratitude for kindnesses conferred, and they have been groping for a number of decades to explain the Jewish religion, not to themselves, but to the great outer world which, it was assumed, was watching its liberated Jews to see if they deserved liberty. The result is a large number of Jews who lack a grasp on the reason for being Jews and think they are filling their highest destiny in an excessive desire to conform and to compromise. Necessarily, they have not in mind Jewish ideals, except, perhaps, those ideals which breathe the vague and unvital content that passes for prophetic Judaism, a product of anarchistic American Jewry.

,What does this class forget? It forgets that the education of Jews must be peculiar.Though we may doubt the oft-declared superiority of the Jewish people when vaunted by thosewho do their best to dissolve it into thin air; in this respect we must be agreed: That a people which has passed through centuries bearing the burden of Christian hatred, persecuted incommon, reading a common literature, hoping for a common freedom, and living the same lifefor centuries and centuries, that such a people must retain a peculiar psychology which demands a peculiar education. Let us not be deluded by the plausible surface indications. Amatter of a century's veneering will not remove the impress of centuries of common danger,and common hope, and common life. Let us not think that a reform violently begun andviolently continued, living for but half a century, will so change Jewish character as to makeit pass for the all inclusive cosmopolitanism which can brother it with either the Hottentotor the representative of Anglo-Saxon civilization.

It is one of the misguided ideas of the day, due to rapid changes in methods of education, that teachers are also students. That is half true. The teacher must be a student of that which he teaches at the time. He cannot meet his pupils with half his subject in the obscurity of confused expression. He cannot write Jewish text-books when he is as yet tangled in his mind and muddled in his statements as to the very principles which he is to inculcate.

Admitting that reform Judaism is the result of reasonable evolution, that it was a necessity of the time, has the clearness of its statements of differences justified its right to teach? Is it competent in truth to teach when it lacks the constructive power to justify its own reform, or even to state it in a lucid manner? We are believers in freedom. We believe in the right of the human soul to interpret life in its own terms, but we do not believe in a vague, inconsistent disagreement that would be an instructor in the ways of life, and yet stumbles every time it tries to move ahead. Reform Judaism has attempted to change the mould of the Jewish religion. It found a creedless religion, based on strong racial or national brotherhood; with one sweep it cut away the national and racial bonds, in violation of all the laws of human nature, and then sought to unite the scattered fragments into some presentable theological creed which it hammered out of its own desires. So colorless and so impossible seems the Jewish theology thus formed, that we now find a vague longing for a sort of historic Judaism in lieu of the intangible prophetic Judaism which it is slowly abandoning.

I speak thus of reform Judaism because the history of Jewish education in America is the attempt to reform Judaism to perpetuate itself. Orthodoxy has so far played little part in the progress of the Jewish people in America because of its disinclination to enter its life. Reform Judaism is responsible for what we understand by American Jewish education.

Now, what has it done in the way of education? Truth, it is said of Russian diplomacy, is not for foreign export. With the Jewish people, too, truth has become so precious that we are loath to speak of it before the "stranger." It is only recently that we have become inflated with this idea that to insure our acceptance by the world we must appear well in it. So we have been painting our weeds to resemble fine lilies, and our unpardonable mistakes have been veneered to resemble fine marble. And especially are we so careful in our boasted attempts in education.