The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
33printed page
scan 28 of 86
July, 1903.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
22

But on every test of fact the consistent and logical system I have outlined stands condemned as unnatural and impracticable, utterly foreign to genius of Judaism. If the emphasis of our faith were on ideas, then would Judaism have been just what it was always farthest from: a religious metaphysics, a standard theology, a clear-cut system of ethics; but if it has avoided anything most studiously, it has been just this very crystallizing of speculation, dogma, and theorem. It has been a religion of conduct, of discipline; it ever preferred observance to dogma, precept to philosopheme, inspired dream to theological speculation. We may prate as we please about the missionary purpose of our dispersion; we may exaggerate as we like what religious ferment we have unwittingly furnished during our dispersion; our unreligious lives, our supremacy as religious indifferents in this indifferent day make all such pretensions sadly ridiculous; I might say, tragically satirical. The utter failure of the Sunday service to wield the faintest religious influence on either Jew or Gentile, our own nullity, individually and collectively, in the gigantic religious agitations of our age, ought to open our eyes to the hollow mockery of any such pretense as this that, neutralized as our individuality is in a dozen national atmospheres, we shall ever be anything else, religiously, than non-descripts.

Consistency, philosophical, historical, practical, I can find only in the radicalism of the other theory which enthrones the life, rather than the mere thought, a life which realizes the thought, as complete and veritable Judaism. According to this theory Judaism is a life to be progressively embodied in a race. Whether we can apply the term "race" with technical accuracy or not, this much is sure—that casual admixtures have never interfered perceptibly with the clearly marked individuality of the Jew or with his progressive development. The history of Judaism has been a history, not so much of advancing thought, but of progressive discipline; when we shall truly understand Judaism, we shall view it not as an idea which gathers clearness and recognition, but as a discipline which steadily gains in universality and force of habit. Judaism, from the very first, has been a plan of national education rather than an unveiling of profound verities; it is, as a course of training alone, that its history presents itself in the light of a steady progress, that the Diaspora appears as an advance in Israel's Lehrjahre, that the present still holds in it the promise of unbounded development. Judaism did not reach its highest point in the grand universal dreams of the prophets; they were the pathfinders, they planned and designed the direction and aim of progress; the rabbis crystallized the Jewish consciousness and gave body to Judaism by translating aspiration into habit, righteousness into precept, conviction into daily discipline. The moral development is fundamental in Judaism, it underlies and explains such religious truths as those to which Judaism rose. At the base of the national character lay an impatient radicalism to which impurity was an abomination, injustice, especially to the helpless, an outrage. This nation, consequently, conceived a God, utterly free from anything lascivious; a God whose fury was aroused on behalf of the weak; a holy and righteous God. These may have been revulsions from the horrors of the environment; but the germs for this conception lay in the national genius. The holy God, to whom all earthly grossness is disgusting, must become, in time, a spiritual deity; the angry God, who avenges foul wrong, becomes a merciful and long-suffering Father, a universal God of peace and brotherhood. Personal purity and tender kindliness lie at the root of Judaism. We shall need to enter more thoroughly into the civilization of the Ghetto to understand how far, against adverse conditions, these religious instincts developed the family life and the spirit of kindliness which are, in addition to his temperamental intensity, the most prominent characteristics of the Jew.

Some of these traits have been stimulated and refined by the noble self-consciousness of historical information; others are being lost by assimilative abrasion and by that shame of national identity which shuns peculiarity as crime. Dispersion has educated the Jew in a hard school; it eliminated unfit elements, diversified the type, it afforded boundless opportunities for acquiring from other nations whatever proved congenial to the Jewish individuality; but it created no opportunity for Jewish religious influence; rather it utterly destroyed whatever proselytizing enthusiasm did undoubtedly exist in the Jew, prior to the Diaspora. The Jewish popular consciousness even now, with its lukewarm attitude toward no matter how sincere a